Example how to compromise your system: I send your friend a message with some random data and pretend to be you. Now he doesn't know what's going on and you two are out of sync and cannot securely re-sync your keys without meeting up again.
[1] https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2009/09/the_doghouse_...
Or if there's a new advance in algebraic cryptanalysis.
Not true. AES does not suffer from the same weaknesses as many public key schemes. A quantum computer could speed up an attack on AES, but does not fundamentally break it.
> Or if there's a new advance in algebraic cryptanalysis.
Sure. But my point was that there are much weaker points than the encryption in a communication system.
I did have a better argument here. It was point 2.
Unauthenticated encryption is dangerous:
https://paragonie.com/blog/2015/05/using-encryption-and-auth...
Wish you had made a better argument here, for perhaps I'm missing it. Yep, key management is a problem. That's all I got, and I know there had to be more.
Do you know of any longer treatments of this subject? Sure would love to read them.
I mean, I'm thinking if I want to share data with a friend, I get a hardware true RNG, cut a couple of 1TB SSDs full of random noise, and hand him a copy. With that amount of data, I'm thinking he and I are good to go for the rest of our lives. (Of course, commercial applications have other constraints)