News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Trucks Are Killing Us by Aloha on Saturday August 22, 2015 @02:14PM (#10103217)
The article bothered me because of the presumption that the author made about hours of service, and as a former driver, in my opinion the issue is not the HOS (hours of service) rules, its the way companies, especially many smaller ones dispatch their drivers - you can be expected to go from working days, to working nights instantly, and it can really fuck hardcore with your sleep schedule - so while you can be compliant with the HOS, you've still not slept any - because you just spent 4 days working days, and now you're expected to pick up a shipment at 11pm and run with it until out of hours for the day.. not practical or safe.

The other thing that irritated me was the presumption that trucks have no safety hardware - I personally wouldn't want to drive a truck with collision avoidance stuff, not unless I had a ton of time to spend with it to understand what it does in an activated situation - that said, most trucks do have ABS, airbags are meaningless in a truck, you're so much larger than the other vehicles that a driver doesn't need airbags to stay safe, and airbags do nothing to enhance the other drivers safety, they just add cost for no real benefit.

Re:Trucks Are Killing Us by rcthompson on Saturday August 22, 2015 @02:27PM (#10103269)
What would you think of a rule that said you could only continue driving if you have slept for at least 6 of the past 24 hours? (I'm not sure what the exact numbers should be, but you get the idea.)
Re:Trucks Are Killing Us by Aloha on Saturday August 22, 2015 @03:00PM (#10103358)
It would be resoundingly ignored, and its utterly unenforceable.

Right now, if you're a driver and you decline a load, it may be days to get another one at times, especially if you're stuck in a city with a ton of inbound freight, but not too much outbound freight - so you take what you can, push your endurance, and hope you can get far enough out of town that they wont try to swap it on you.

Re:Trucks Are Killing Us by kw71 on Saturday August 22, 2015 @06:12PM (#10103967)
I think it's unenforceable with the current infrastructure.

In Europe, trucks are required to have chart recorders called tachographs. You put one chart in the machine per day and that's your log. I think this makes it a lot more difficult to keep two logs, and now there are computerized tachograph recorders which should be even more resistant to tampering (ie. they can get the current date and time from a trusted source such as mobile network, tv broadcast, or GPS.)

Re:Trucks Are Killing Us by kolinko on Saturday August 22, 2015 @07:14PM (#10104151)
It still doesn't help if you switch driver's schedule from night to day.

If monday tuesday and wednesday you drove through the day, and then friday evening they tell you to take a night course, then the tahoraph will say thay you had enough rest, while you will still get sleepy in the middle of night.

In other words - tachograph will tell you whether the driver had a break, not whether he slept properly during that break.

Re:Trucks Are Killing Us by stefantalpalaru on Saturday August 22, 2015 @08:17PM (#10104293)
It's more or less the same situation you see in health-care providers doing a night shift immediately after the day shift. Not ideal, but they do get more free time to compensate afterwards.

European trucking laws are quite sane. From http://ec.europa.eu/transport/road_safety/users/professional... :

"Driving time should not exceed 9 hours a day or 56 hours a week. After 4½ hours, drivers must take a break of at least 45 minutes."

Re:Trucks Are Killing Us by mcguire on Saturday August 22, 2015 @05:24PM (#10103830)
"It would be resoundingly ignored, and its utterly unenforceable."

My understanding is that currently, a driver has essentially three states: on-duty, driving; on-duty, not driving; and off-duty. Further, as I understand it, strictness about maintaining logs and electronic log books (which drivers like, judging by the ads I see for it) have made fudging duty hours much less of a problem now than in the good ol' amphetamine days.

You can force a driver to go off duty, but you can't force him to sleep. And the driver hours-of-service regulations are insane.[1]

[1] http://www.fmcsa.dot.gov/regulations/hours-service/summary-h...

Re:Trucks Are Killing Us by op00to on Saturday August 22, 2015 @05:03PM (#10103743)
... So obviously the solution is to keep killing motorists so you can get a paycheck. Gotcha.
Re:Trucks Are Killing Us by Aloha on Saturday August 22, 2015 @05:40PM (#10103878)
The article is weasel worded, frankly.

In 2013 there were 32,719 vehicle related deaths in the US, 3,964 of them involved a 'large truck' in other words about 12.5% of total deaths.

According to the IIHS - the number of fatalities per 100 million miles traveled is significantly lower (.88 for passenger vehicles in a large truck involved crash and .21 for occupants of large trucks) than the average for all vehicle (1.10) - and in just 15 (1998) years the numbers have declined significantly (from 1.67 and .37, and 1.8 respectively).

I'd be happy to hear what your solution to the problem is, I realize any death at all is a shame, but nothing can be made 100% safe - statistically, you're at a greater risk of dying of stomach cancer, suicide or malaria - than you are to die in a vehicle accident of any kind (11.6 deaths per 100,000 in the US), or for that matter you're more likely to die of Melanoma, Hepatitis B or an Upper Respiratory Infection then you are to die in an accident with a large truck (.9 deaths per 100,000 in the US are involving a large truck).

The solutions are neither clear, nor easy, but if you have one, I'd be open to ideas.

Re:Trucks Are Killing Us by URSpider94 on Saturday August 22, 2015 @05:23PM (#10103827)
Drivers are fallible human beings. With families. And car payments. And mortgages. Many of them own their own trucks, and have to make payments on those as well. I'm pretty damned sure that nobody goes out on the road thinking that they're going to kill someone, while destroying their livelihood and injuring themselves in the process.

If you knew that the difference between working today and not being able to work for another several days was to put in a few extra hours, are you telling me you'd never make that same decision yourself?

Re:Trucks Are Killing Us by BurningFrog on Saturday August 22, 2015 @02:41PM (#10103306)
Sounds like a sensible rule that is impossible to enforce.
Re:Trucks Are Killing Us by MrBuddyCasino on Saturday August 22, 2015 @03:27PM (#10103448)
In Germany, trucks are required to have trip recorders. The police can (and will) check them to see if the minimum resting times were observed. Don't american trucks have something similar?
Re:Trucks Are Killing Us by nickff on Saturday August 22, 2015 @04:37PM (#10103662)
Logs are kept, but the posts above are making the point that drivers should be required to sleep a certain number of hours of the past 24 hours. Logs do not help you with this, unless you are using a sleep tracking device.
Re:Trucks Are Killing Us by michaelt on Saturday August 22, 2015 @05:02PM (#10103738)
If your legal standard is "no more than 10 hours driving in any continuous 24 hour period, and at least 9 hours of continuous rest period" you don't know for /sure/ that the driver will sleep in the 14 hours they're not driving, but why wouldn't he/she?
Re:Trucks Are Killing Us by MichaelGG on Saturday August 22, 2015 @05:15PM (#10103790)
I guess it's because they might be shifting to a new schedule and it wasn't feasible to change sleep patterns? So if you get in at 00:00 one day, sleep until 08:00. Then you don't get a new assignment until 02:00 the next day day, you will have the necessary gap, but not have had any real way to have slept the right time. You would have needed to force yourself to sleep in the afternoon/evening, and, even with drugs, that is a hard thing to pull off.
Re:Trucks Are Killing Us by mcguire on Saturday August 22, 2015 @05:28PM (#10103839)
I believe the industry successfully fought off a simple hours-of-service schedule like that several years ago. Instead, you have: http://www.fmcsa.dot.gov/regulations/hours-service/summary-h....
Re:Trucks Are Killing Us by BurningFrog on Sunday August 23, 2015 @10:10AM (#10105526)
Not everyone is blessed with the capacity to sleep at will.
Re:Trucks Are Killing Us by ihaveajob on Monday August 24, 2015 @11:32AM (#10110514)
They do, in all western countries I know of. But that log can't check hours of sleep by the driver. On the other hand, this might be a whole new business segment for Fitbit and the like.
Re:Trucks Are Killing Us by kw71 on Saturday August 22, 2015 @06:14PM (#10103974)
Nope, logs are all manual entries on sheets of paper.
Re:Trucks Are Killing Us by lsc on Saturday August 22, 2015 @06:35PM (#10104031)
https://www.speedgauge.net/

I only know about this 'cause I know some of their sysadmins. but there's a whole industry of automated truck-tracking and truck-activity logging out there.

Most of it, I think, is focused on reducing liability/reducing insurance costs, I think; I don't think most of it is legally mandated.

Note, I've also heard from other people who's pagers go off when certain devices can't resolve GPS signals that a common cause of their pager going off is a trucker driving by with a GPS jammer that was being used to defeat one of these automatic truck logging deals.

So... yeah, it's not legally mandated or anything, but automatic logging of truck activity and speed is pretty common.

Re:Trucks Are Killing Us by L_Rahman on Saturday August 22, 2015 @09:43PM (#10104462)
It is legally mandated now, and the fleets have till 2018 to implement automated truck-tracking. I work at an enterprise hardware company and we get lots of inbound customer inquiries from logistics companies in the trucking space.
Re:Trucks Are Killing Us by MichaelGG on Saturday August 22, 2015 @05:10PM (#10103772)
Pilots have rules like that and they seem to work. But I suppose the massive regulation of airline safety makes it rather much easier to implement.

But how are they enforcing the anti drug stuff? A relative is a trucker and I recall him telling me it wasn't worth screwing around with alertness meds (speed, modafinil, etc) due to risks of getting caught. (And some similar stuff for taking on passengers/hitchhikers?) Seems like if that kind of oversight is in place then adding sleep restrictions is not hard.

Or do you mean that they'd technically have had enough time to sleep, but in reality they weren't actually sleeping, but short of invasive biomonitoring it's impossible to tell? (One could be in bed, reading, for example.)

Re:Trucks Are Killing Us by BurningFrog on Sunday August 23, 2015 @10:09AM (#10105519)
Yeah, you can monitor the vehicle, but to ensure people sleep you'd need to enforce video evidence at least.

Maybe people with no experience of insomnia just don't consider the possibility.

Re:Trucks Are Killing Us by ivanca on Saturday August 22, 2015 @03:41PM (#10103495)
Easy enough, with the help of a GPS you can check that the driver can't be on the move for more than 16 hours straigh without an 8-hours reccess. If he wants to do something else instead of sleep that's his problem.
Re:Trucks Are Killing Us by Aloha on Saturday August 22, 2015 @03:00PM (#10103359)
Agreed.
Re:Trucks Are Killing Us by tetraodonpuffer on Saturday August 22, 2015 @04:23PM (#10103638)
even if you enforce that it's still not gonna help with the fact that as much as people would like it circadian rhythms don't adjust instantly. Ever changing shifts are the bane of a good existence, working nights all the time is fine, working nights a week every 2-3 or worse, 2-3 days a week, is going to cause a lot of problems for everybody.

From my perspective I would totally gamify cars/trucks for everybody, every time you want to go somewhere you get your reflexes tested, if your reaction time is higher than a certain amount the car won't start. This will catch anybody who is too tired just as well as anybody who has been drinking I would think, which in the end works about the same when it comes to road safety.

Re:Trucks Are Killing Us by hyperpape on Saturday August 22, 2015 @05:15PM (#10103793)
Sounds foolproof. The first time someone can't start their car when they need it because of a glitch in your software/inaccuracies in the testing method, you are in serious trouble.
Re:Trucks Are Killing Us by tetraodonpuffer on Monday August 24, 2015 @10:31AM (#10110014)
isn't there already plenty of software involved in starting your car that could have bugs and prevent it from starting? I don't think an embedded reaction time test is that hard to get right compared to the software that has to deal with the engine internals and so on.
Re:Trucks Are Killing Us by hyperpape on Monday August 24, 2015 @10:59PM (#10114336)
As a rule, things involving human action are unreliable and suffer from false positives.
Re:Trucks Are Killing Us by stcredzero on Saturday August 22, 2015 @05:03PM (#10103746)
you can be expected to go from working days, to working nights instantly, and it can really fuck hardcore with your sleep schedule

The same thing happened to me when I was working the Halibut opener in Alaska. Switching to a midnight to noon shift can wreak havoc with your sleep cycle, and it is very hard to avoid falling asleep while driving. Happened to me.

Re:Trucks Are Killing Us by cb18 on Saturday August 22, 2015 @08:38PM (#10104340)
* its the way companies, especially many smaller ones dispatch their drivers - you can be expected to go from working days, to working nights instantly, and it can really fuck hardcore with your sleep schedule*

Yeah, that is ridiculous, and it would only take some slight adjustment in the dispatch software to keep people on their accustomed schedules. It might require drawing potential drivers from a slightly larger area or something.

It sounds like just about the last thing on these companies minds is the safety of road users. Maybe their needs to be a fine imposed on them for every accident above the already too high non-truck accident rate.

Re:Trucks Are Killing Us by Silhouette on Saturday August 22, 2015 @03:43PM (#10103503)
as a former driver, in my opinion the issue is not the HOS (hours of service) rules, its the way companies, especially many smaller ones dispatch their drivers

I don't doubt you about the dispatch issues. The article itself mentioned that the driver of the truck that caused a fatal accident had spent 12 hours driving from his home to pick up the truck before then spending 13.5 of the permitted 14 hours driving the truck at the time of the accident, and had been awake for 28 hours straight.

But isn't the idea that anyone can safely handle that kind of vehicle for 82 hours per week also a bit crazy? That's roughly working 14 hours/day for 6 days/week. That's almost double what we'd allow here in the UK, for example.

Re:Trucks Are Killing Us by Aloha on Saturday August 22, 2015 @05:48PM (#10103899)
The rules are 11/14/70.

11 Hours driving maximum per day, 14 hours on duty maximum per day, and 70 hours maximum per rolling 8 day period (or 60 hours per rolling 7 day period).

Between driving periods, you must take 8 hours + 2 hours (most drivers just do a 10 hour rest period) in the sleeper berth. If you take 34 hours (knows as a reset) off duty, your rolling HOS clock resets to 0 and you can drive a full 70 again.

Being awake for me, and functional for 14-18 hours continuous is never a problem for me, but when I drove I avoided being in a urban area when I was that tired - I'd stop short, sleep outside of town, and head in in the morning to drop the load at the receiver usually.

Re:Trucks Are Killing Us by mcguire on Saturday August 22, 2015 @05:12PM (#10103778)
"I personally wouldn't want to drive a truck with collision avoidance stuff, not unless I had a ton of time to spend with it to understand what it does in an activated situation..."

I have no solid information about this, but I recently heard a driver complaining about some form of collision avoidance technology that had a tendency to malfunction on a loaded vehicle and was responsible for "putting trucks is the ditch".

Any idea what he was talking about?

Re:Trucks Are Killing Us by Aloha on Sunday August 23, 2015 @03:45PM (#10106522)
I don't - I've been out of the industry for a while now. But, I can tell you, the vehicle dynamics of a large truck are significantly different than a car, and in many situations such an unexpected change could cause an accident.

With a car, you're only concerned about keeping one braking system in repair, when hauling a trailer you get a roll of the die every time you pick up a new trailer, some of them track straight, some of them don't - some of them brake asymmetrically side to side too.

Air Brakes are also a completely different dynamic then hydraulic brakes used in cars, in a way I can't even reasonably explain, its just something you need to experience - but to give you a clue, you don't feel brake fade as a difference in pedal back pressure, your brakes just don't work as well.

Consider this - the old adage when driving a combined tractor trailer is - "you're driving the trailer, not the truck"

Re:Trucks Are Killing Us by snarfy on Sunday August 23, 2015 @12:03AM (#10104641)
If the government is going to regulate the hours per week, they should be regulating the schedule too. They wouldn't let a commercial jet pilot switch schedules like that.
Re:Trucks Are Killing Us by rhizome on Saturday August 22, 2015 @05:05PM (#10103755)
An Uber for truck shipping, I See A Great Need.
Re:Trucks Are Killing Us by mcguire on Saturday August 22, 2015 @05:30PM (#10103845)
As in, something that doesn't have an hours-of-service regulation?