News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:JFK Displays Actual Wait Times Using Beacons That Monitor... by gorena on Friday August 21, 2015 @11:21AM (#10098079)
Serious question: if there is a 16 minute queue for "security", why wouldn't a potential terrorist just wheel up a carry on sized bomb and detonate it in the middle of the "security" line? Is this something that the TSA addresses (I assume not), or do they just ignore the possibility? All they've done is move the soft target further out.
Re:JFK Displays Actual Wait Times Using Beacons That Monitor... by harmegido on Friday August 21, 2015 @11:31AM (#10098143)
I think they're concern is not foremost for the safety of the passengers. The main concern is airplanes going into buildings. Of course, this is definitely an example of fighting the last war.

On a separate note, the TSA really pisses me off. Consider that UPS saves millions by not taking left turns. Removing or adding very small inefficiencies at a very large scale has tremendous cost implications. I don't think these security lines add much security and I think they do that task at a much higher cost than most people think.

Re:JFK Displays Actual Wait Times Using Beacons That Monitor... by digi_owl on Friday August 21, 2015 @11:39AM (#10098193)
IF you look at airport security, it is always about fighting the last war. The limitation on liquids comes a lone bomber bringing a liquid binary explosive onboard in the toiletry. the issue with shoes, again another bomber. matching luggage to passengers i believe is because of Lockerbie. And the list goes on and on.
Re:JFK Displays Actual Wait Times Using Beacons That Monitor... by mikeash on Friday August 21, 2015 @12:26PM (#10098558)
If you're in a position to make these decisions, your career will be wrecked if an attack is repeated successfully, but you'll probably be just fine if a new attack gets through.
Re:JFK Displays Actual Wait Times Using Beacons That Monitor... by digi_owl on Friday August 21, 2015 @02:12PM (#10099248)
Sounds somewhat like a inverse Lucas Critique...
Re:JFK Displays Actual Wait Times Using Beacons That Monitor... by MBlume on Friday August 21, 2015 @11:40AM (#10098201)
I agree that planes going into buildings is the major security concern, but we fixed it. We've reinforced the cockpit doors and we've taught passengers not to cooperate with hijackers (the latter we managed within hours of the first attack)
Re:JFK Displays Actual Wait Times Using Beacons That Monitor... by UnoriginalGuy on Friday August 21, 2015 @12:08PM (#10098407)
Plus panic buttons & guns in the cockpit, new procedures for aircraft leaving their scheduled route, and passenger's reaction to a hijacking (e.g. one "bad guy" with a switchblade is nothing against 300 people who fear NOT doing anything will endanger their lives).
Re:JFK Displays Actual Wait Times Using Beacons That Monitor... by tdfw on Friday August 21, 2015 @03:12PM (#10099618)
Pilots have a panic button. It's called squawking code 7500. Alerts ATC that there is a hijacking situation (7700 is general emergency.) Guns in airplanes are a bad idea for, well, quite a few reasons.
Re:JFK Displays Actual Wait Times Using Beacons That Monitor... by jessaustin on Friday August 21, 2015 @01:48PM (#10099086)
...we've taught passengers not to cooperate with hijackers

Since I'm old, I remember the decades during which we were taught to cooperate completely with hijackers. Of course this was always bad advice, as was eventually made clear even to the idiots on TV. It seems possible that if no terrorism "expert" had ever appeared on TV, 9/11 could have gone very differently.

Re:JFK Displays Actual Wait Times Using Beacons That Monitor... by lojack on Friday August 21, 2015 @12:23PM (#10098525)
While all of this helps, it's hard to say that it fixed the issue. As far as I'm aware, for US based flights, there have been a few bombing attempts, but no hijacking attempt since 9/11. It's hard to say if this is a result of these security measures, the TSA security, or just the fact that hijackings aren't that common.
Re:JFK Displays Actual Wait Times Using Beacons That Monitor... by vidarh on Friday August 21, 2015 @12:11PM (#10098435)
> we've taught passengers not to cooperate with hijackers

Have we? Maybe US passengers have been taught that better than elsewhere, but we don't really know due to the lack of hijackings to test that theory.

And internationally, of about a dozen hijackings post 9/11 only two I think have seen the hijacker get subdued by passengers - in one instance probably because there happened to be six police officers aboard; in the other instance it was a lone hijacker with a nail file...

Incidentally, despite 9/11, the odds of surviving a plane hijacking are still very high - the persons running the highest risk of getting killed in a hijacking are the hijackers. As it happens, 9/11 did not result in a string of copycat hijackers - most hijackers appears to still plan to survive the hijacking.

Re:JFK Displays Actual Wait Times Using Beacons That Monitor... by rayiner on Friday August 21, 2015 @12:10PM (#10098429)
It's not like we didn't have airport security lines before the TSA. And with the new millimeter wave machines I'm not sure if they're appreciably slower than the old metal detector setup. The bottleneck was always putting your luggage through the X-ray, and we've had that for as long as I can remember.
Re:JFK Displays Actual Wait Times Using Beacons That Monitor... by Thriptic on Friday August 21, 2015 @12:30PM (#10098590)
I don't have the data to back it up, but from what I have personally seen, the bottleneck is now predominantly the body scanner, mostly because many airports are running a setup where they have two x-ray baggage detector lines feeding into one body scanner.
Re:JFK Displays Actual Wait Times Using Beacons That Monitor... by rhino369 on Friday August 21, 2015 @04:40PM (#10100087)
The bottleneck is definitely the xray scanners. I've never seen the line be held up by people waiting for millimeter wave machine. Also, if that line gets even a little long, the TSA agent will wave people through the metal detector real quick.

That said, things like taking your shoes off, taking your laptop out, removing belts, etc. really slow down the xray machine line.

Re:JFK Displays Actual Wait Times Using Beacons That Monitor... by Thriptic on Friday August 21, 2015 @06:03PM (#10100516)
To be fair my observations are solely based off n~= 20 flights through generally smaller airports, but I have seen extreme reluctance on the part of TSA staff to pass people through the metal detectors, especially during times like holidays. I do agree that the security theater surrounding the x-ray bag scanners is also a significant issue and might be the primary bottleneck at other airports or at different times.
Re:JFK Displays Actual Wait Times Using Beacons That Monitor... by jessaustin on Friday August 21, 2015 @01:55PM (#10099139)
When I was flying in continental USA on a weekly basis in 1998-99, security lines were seldom a problem. On more than one occasion, I parked my car in the DIA short-term lot (client was paying) 20 minutes before flight time. Gate agents would wag their fingers, and I'd be breathing hard when I got aboard, but I never missed a plane because of it. Also when I forgot to stash my pocketknife in my carry-on bag I just plunked it down in the change bucket with my keys and change. It really was easier and more enjoyable to fly back then...
Re:JFK Displays Actual Wait Times Using Beacons That Monitor... by dragonwriter on Friday August 21, 2015 @02:26PM (#10099342)
If you think it was a joy to fly then, you should have seen it before the security measures adopted around the time of the 1990-1991 Gulf War and associated perception that Iraq would target US flights for terrorist attacks.
Re:JFK Displays Actual Wait Times Using Beacons That Monitor... by harryh on Friday August 21, 2015 @04:43PM (#10100107)
I think the key bottleneck increaser was the requirement to remove shoes and to remove more things (electronics & liquids) from luggage when being sent through the x-ray.
Re:JFK Displays Actual Wait Times Using Beacons That Monitor... by remarkEon on Friday August 21, 2015 @12:08PM (#10098412)
-> ...why wouldn't a potential terrorist just wheel up a carry on sized bomb and detonate it in the middle of the "security" line?

I have no idea. To me, by far the most dangerous part of flying is the queue at the TSA checkpoints, especially at airports with particularly large checkpoints (I'm thinking EWR and probably ORD). I think some airports address this (SEA, MSP, JFK...maybe) by spreading out the checkpoints among smaller groups of gates to keep the volume of people at those checkpoints down. This is just my speculation, however.

I'd be curious to see how checkpoints have evolved over the last 14 years in terms of design and efficiency.

Re:JFK Displays Actual Wait Times Using Beacons That Monitor... by mpeg on Friday August 21, 2015 @11:23AM (#10098088)
Airport security is there to protect the planes, not the passengers.
Re:JFK Displays Actual Wait Times Using Beacons That Monitor... by bosdev on Friday August 21, 2015 @12:04PM (#10098379)
* Airport security is there to protect the airline industry, not the planes or passengers
Re:JFK Displays Actual Wait Times Using Beacons That Monitor... by forgottenpass on Friday August 21, 2015 @12:31PM (#10098601)
When it comes to designing airport safety, instilling the feeling of safety in travelers is a more important goal than actual safety. This is a sorta-open-secret.

We can sit around and come up with thousands of possible attacks scenarios with less than 1% of the security that goes into preventing airplane hijackings. But that doesn't really matter. Airport security is primarily a political item, both responding to political pressures and fears, while generating entirely new ones.

Re:JFK Displays Actual Wait Times Using Beacons That Monitor... by matthewmacleod on Friday August 21, 2015 @11:25AM (#10098094)
Setting aside the effectiveness arguments for the moment, the point of preventing weapons on aircraft is now less about 'a terrorist might blow up an aircraft' and more about 'a terrorist might hijack an aircraft and turn it into a gigantic missile'.

Obviously any place where there are large groups of people would be a target for attacks of this kind.

Re:JFK Displays Actual Wait Times Using Beacons That Monitor... by 6d0debc071 on Friday August 21, 2015 @12:28PM (#10098574)
I imagine the reasoning goes somewhat to the effect of:

If a plane goes down, it's reasonable to expect that everyone on board will die. It's less reasonable to expect that the blast radius of a device that was sufficient to down an aircraft would be sufficient to encompass an equivalent number of people in the security line.

Re:JFK Displays Actual Wait Times Using Beacons That Monitor... by smackfu on Friday August 21, 2015 @12:07PM (#10098403)
At a lot of more risky countries, they do x-ray / metal detector every passenger at the airport entrance.

I assume that's to prevent targeting concentrations of foreign tourists.

Re:JFK Displays Actual Wait Times Using Beacons That Monitor... by molotv on Friday August 21, 2015 @12:43PM (#10098680)
In Newark, past the TSA checkpoints, the Tel Aviv gate has its own secondary screening with barricades, wands & pat-downs for everyone. I suspect that is because of actual threats and a desire for real security.
Re:JFK Displays Actual Wait Times Using Beacons That Monitor... by remarkEon on Friday August 21, 2015 @12:09PM (#10098421)
This just moves the target from the indoor TSA queue to curbside.
Re:JFK Displays Actual Wait Times Using Beacons That Monitor... by saryant on Friday August 21, 2015 @11:23AM (#10098089)
Sort of like how they take those super-dangerous bottles of water and toiletries and place them in a secure receptacle AKA a trash can.
Re:JFK Displays Actual Wait Times Using Beacons That Monitor... by pyre on Friday August 21, 2015 @11:29AM (#10098127)
I thought the idea wasn't that they were volatile on their own, but components that could be assembled into a bomb once on-plane.
Re:JFK Displays Actual Wait Times Using Beacons That Monitor... by vidarh on Friday August 21, 2015 @12:21PM (#10098515)
That might have helped if they actually caught fluids in the carry on. In my experience (accidentally left bottles in carry-on several times; always found out myself after passing through security with no problems) they don't seem to do that.
Re:JFK Displays Actual Wait Times Using Beacons That Monitor... by pyre on Friday August 21, 2015 @01:30PM (#10098981)
It's inconsistent. I've had various things denied in carry-on (e.g. jar of jam, snow globe, etc). A TSA agent even told me that snow globes were not allowed even in checked luggage, which I found out later is false. I had to find some way to mail the snow globe to myself from the airport.