Re:Petition UK government to not ban encryption
by tormeh on Friday August 21, 2015 @10:15AM
(#10097584)
>What is written is what is valid, not what you think it should mean
I am not sure if it would be a good thing or not if this was the case, but leaving that aside laws are, in fact, liberally interpreted all the time, depending on your jurisdiction's legal tradition. This is why you can't hack the law; the interpretation of the law will change to fill in the gaps, provided that's what the justice system wants.
Re:Petition UK government to not ban encryption
by untog on Friday August 21, 2015 @10:37AM
(#10097729)
"means of communication" is a quote from David Cameron, and is not the actual valid text of a law. It's hardly uncommon for a politician to sum up the intent of a law while not using the precise language used inside it.
In any case, there is no law yet, so no language to examine.
Re:Petition UK government to not ban encryption
by sillygeese on Friday August 21, 2015 @11:01PM
(#10101349)
Oh right, because laws are ironclad codifications of pure, unadulterated Justice, and that's exactly why you can be imprisoned for collecting rainwater on your property: http://cnsnews.com/news/article/oregon-man-sentenced-30-days...
In reality, the correct way to interpret laws is to think about their real purpose. Who benefits? What is the goal here?
The vast majority of laws have one of these two purposes: to enrich the government's cronies, or to cement the government's continued rule.
As yourself used the term, how is "communication between a bank and a customer" not a form of "communication"?