You should give it another look. My team's used it for a mission critical project for over a decade. It's older and more mature than ext4, IMO. For sustained write throughput, it does much better than ext4. That said, many folks have utilization which looks more like random I/O than sequential.
Are you sure it was worse than ext2/3?
[ed: Looks like it might be better/as good as ext2, but somewhat worse than ext3/4 -- apparently xfs jourunals only metadata: http://superuser.com/questions/84257/xfs-and-loss-of-data-wh...
Still doesn't seem like it destroy's data on powerloss -- just the usual - if data isn't written to disk, then it's not written to disk.]
IIRC (and I'm a bit hazy) here were other issues too that have been since fixed. The long delay between write and commit meant that a lot of bugs that would otherwise have been vanishingly rare got exposed. Likely the ext systems have/had similar bugs that just have only happened a single digit number of times in the past 20 years.
The inevitable results of applications developed for ext3 running on other file systems incurring data loss on system crashes then got blamed on those other filesystems (including ext4, ironically).
And the thing with filesystems is that the format can't really change once stable - and you get locked into an architecture that dictates an awful lot about what features you can provide. So if you want to add zfs-like features to a linux fs that doesn't eat your data/have abysmal performance (btrfs) then you're basically back at square 0 and you have to write a new one.
"[..] the main goal of bcachefs to match ext4 and xfs on performance and reliability, but with the features of btrfs/zfs."
on Kent's benchmarks, something is up with the results in the thousands of MB/s - high end flash is fast but not that fast unless the entire transaction is possibly taking place in RAM cache instead of on the drive - which would explain btrfs having numbers in the hundreds of MB/s instead
Well, Linus took that gamble when he blessed btrfs as the future of Linux filesystems four or five years ago, and it hasn't really worked out as intended.
Before this, EXT4 was the king of metadata-intensive workloads. Nowadays XFS wins.
I'm guessing you used the older code (rhel/centos pre-6.3 perhaps?) and ran into this issue.
http://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=article&item=linux_rai...
F2FS is looking really promising for SSD
ps. Kent's benchmark numbers struck me for one particular aspect I haven't seen in other benchmarks - max latency - and EXT4 is looking darn good in that aspect - I still use EXT4 over XFS, I simply do not trust XFS enough yet