News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Errors and Exceptions by jblow on Friday August 21, 2015 @04:16AM (#10096450)
I also prefer option 3 over option 4. It bothers me that the article recommends exceptions without seeming to understand their drawbacks (the major one: as soon as you use exceptions you suddenly need to apply nonlocal reasoning everywhere in order to understand what your program will do at any point. They turn your program from a simple local thing into a complex nonlocal thing, which is not a good idea if you want to understand it well.)

This article seems not to have a lot in the way of new contribution; it is just parroting the oft-repeated idea that you need exceptions to pass "error information" up several layers of abstraction. But here is what I think about this:

1) In this age when we are realizing strong typing is a good idea, that hidden state is a bad idea, and that in general you should be very specific about what is going on, why are we even conceptualizing this as "error information"? Why instead, when we try to open a file, do we not return "all information you might need to know in the case of opening a file" (which includes what happened if it didn't open properly). As soon as you make that conceptual switch, all this hand-wringing goes away. It's a non-problem. You certainly shouldn't add heinous complications to your program to solve this non-problem.

1a) This conceptual change also helps disambiguate between what the article calls "hard errors" and "soft errors". In portions of the code where you have attempted an operation that might have failed, and you are not completely sure that it didn't fail, you have the full body of "what happened" information (it is a small struct or whatever). After the situation has been checked and you know it is exactly what you need to be, you may drop the other information and pass the raw file handle. At this point it is clear that these parts of the code should only be executed if the file handle is valid, and if that is not true, the programmer made an error. This is analogous to the situation with nullable and non-nullable pointers (in some languages you would even use the same mechanisms to deal with null pointers and invalid file handles, etc, but I am not sure this is really helpful.)

2) If one insists on not making the simplifying leap from (1), well, maybe the other problem is that you have so many layers. If you didn't have so much glue, your code would be simpler and easier to deal with, and it would run faster, and you wouldn't be so worried about needing to pass lots of context information up several layers between modules, because those situations don't really arise.

Re:Errors and Exceptions by barrkel on Friday August 21, 2015 @04:31AM (#10096499)
In this age when we are realizing strong typing is a good idea, that hidden state is a bad idea, and that in general you should be very specific about what is going on

Java tried to be typesafe about errors, about not obscuring the state, and it was a dreadful idea. The way code fails is a function of its implementation; communicating high quality error information is fundamentally an abstraction violation, but a strongly typed facade that forces you to rewrap all your error cases in some other type just obscures the underlying problem.

Strongly typed error information also breaks composability. How do you write a 'map' function that can accept a callback, where the callback may want to communicate back one of several distinct kinds of error information? With unchecked exceptions, the way forward is clear. Without them, you either need to write a lot of boilerplate to unify your error types in some kind of container, or rely on subtyping to fit them into a single type and live with the lack of strong typing via another route.

Dynamically typed programming languages improve usability over statically typed languages particularly when a precise description of the types used in the static case is difficult or tedious to express. Error information, and its intrinsic implementation-dependent content, is one of the strongest instances of this.

Re:Errors and Exceptions by dllthomas on Friday August 21, 2015 @04:43AM (#10096525)
You could have checked exceptions with more flexibility than Java had, and it might work out well (or might break down for other reasons).

"How do you write a 'map' function that can accept a callback, where the callback may want to communicate back one of several distinct kinds of error?"

With Java style checked exceptions, you don't, and that's for sure a problem.

However, one approach would be to say that map is polymorphic in the exceptions that may be raised from within it. But that set is not entirely unbounded - it is precisely the set that can be raised by its function argument, unioned with any that might be raised during traversal of its container argument.

Re:Errors and Exceptions by Animats on Friday August 21, 2015 @03:12PM (#10099617)
Exceptions are hard to get right in language design. They're easier in a garbage-collected language like Python, because there's not so much need to release stuff. Most of the bad reputation of exceptions comes from C++, where the combination of exceptions, RAII, and having to release memory results in problems.

Without exceptions, programs seem to develop too many "goto" statements. Go suffers in this way. Error handling in Rust seems to excessively complex, and hiding the complexity inside macros that do return statements is an ugly solution to the problem.

Re:Errors and Exceptions by kilemensi on Friday August 21, 2015 @05:08AM (#10096592)
For my own understanding, why do you say "(Exceptions) turn your program from a simple local thing into a complex nonlocal thing, which is not a good idea if you want to understand it well."?

My understanding exceptions only bubble up if they weren't handled at the point of failure. This is exactly the same if you don't check the return type of a function that could return error. Both of this situations point to poor programming technique rather than underlying implementation option.

One thing that makes me currently prefer exceptions to error returns is that within a try/with block you can write the code as you'd like to happen and hence easier to understand and maintain. All exception handling can happen within the respective catch blocks.

Re:Errors and Exceptions by jblow on Friday August 21, 2015 @05:33AM (#10096653)
Because in order to know which instructions in your procedure might excecute, you need to know about the exception-handling behavior for everyone you call, which requires looking at the source code of everyone you call. User barkkel above in this thread was saying that passing around full return-value information for something like a file-open operation is somehow a violation of abstraction (this idea does not make sense to me) ... But I can't think of a bigger violation of abstraction than requiring you to know everything about everyone you ever call. Of course in reality people don't do this, which is then why programs that use exceptions have so many problems.

And if you say "why would you let exceptions bubble up that much", well, that is the whole point of exceptions, that they bubble up. If you say "to get rid of nonlocality just catch outside every call", well, now that's equivalent to checking return values always, but more error-prone.

Re:Errors and Exceptions by lukasLansky on Friday August 21, 2015 @06:23AM (#10096746)
Strong type system with a good support of checked exceptions would tell you what kind of exceptions can arise from every function call. If you don't check them in your function code, they would add to the list of exceptions that your function can throw. It would basically turn every function you write with return type T into Either<T, ExceptionA, ExceptionC, ExceptionH> with syntax sugar that would transfer exceptions between calls so you don't have to spend your time with constant transfering of error properties of your return objects.

This would allow you to check stuff on places you desire (sometimes right after function, sometimes in the UI thread) and have tooling support for managing what is left unchecked.

Let's build something like that for C# using Roslyn! Issues of Java-style checked exceptions can be overcome using proper typing with generics.

Re:Errors and Exceptions by einrealist on Friday August 21, 2015 @09:52AM (#10097422)
In layered code, if not recoverable by the current layer, you should always encapsulate checked exceptions thrown by a lower layer - translated into an exception of the current layer (maybe generalized). This simple rule is often declared as overhead. I don't get that. I like code to be precise. The only situations where this gets complicated are those, where the rule is violated. And I think, the rejection of checked exceptions is often based on experiences with bad API design.

Exception handling must be trained and educated. There is no silver bullet.

Re:Errors and Exceptions by jblow on Friday August 21, 2015 @08:36AM (#10097049)
With this scheme you would end up with pretty bad problems regarding function pointers and lambdas. Because the type is deeply implicit, you would have two function pointers that look compatible but are totally incompatible. Then when you want to assign them to a variable -- how do you know a priori what type to declare the variable?
Re:Errors and Exceptions by dllthomas on Friday August 21, 2015 @12:02PM (#10098364)
This would seem to be "just" a matter of correctly handling polymorphism along yet another axis.

Let's say we had the following C++ code:

    int foo(int (*bar)(char), int (*baz)(), char c) {
        try {
            return bar(c)
        } catch(SomeException &e) {
            raise otherexception;
        }
    }
What exceptions can be raised by foo?

The answer is simply computed - "anything raised by its first argument except SomeException, plus the type of otherexception".

Such a system would be tremendously more flexible than Java's checked exceptions, while still allowing you to confidently restrict what might be thrown in a section of code.

Re:Errors and Exceptions by lukasLansky on Friday August 21, 2015 @03:31PM (#10099730)
Good question. :-) I guess there definitely would be cases where the programmer would be restricted in what they want to do -- this is a nature of type systems. For example, I guess following code would not compile:

var f = (n) => n / 5; f = (n) => 5 / n;

What I hope for is that usual patterns would survive in a convenient manner. For example, calling function with function argument that is evaluated inside this function is something that could be handled by language without too many problems.