Re:Are Lawyers Getting Dumber?
by mindslight on Thursday August 20, 2015 @03:19PM
(#10094018)
> you generally could be [successfully] sued if you just took the picture of a random businessman and revealed he was going somewhere other than he told his boss
But is this actually true? (I interpreted you as meaning "successfully sued", as anyone can be sued for anything)
We're not quite at the point where location surveillance companies are selling data B2C directly to the boss. But it's only the mechanism of harm that differs - influencing subjects to make suboptimal decisions and overcharging consumers are these companies' explicit goals!
Not advocating it, just saying the most plausible reason they might have had in mind. I was going to compare it to the case of following someone around, which could be called harassment (and which the businessman might argue), but he would have the defense that "even if I followed these hijacking victims too closely, my presence there was getting something that has a public interest".
Agree though -- I still don't see why you need a legal defense for "filming people as they leave a plane".
Re:Are Lawyers Getting Dumber?
by mindslight on Thursday August 20, 2015 @03:38PM
(#10094128)
I would advocate it if it were actually a thing, since it would create an individual avenue of action against private mass surveillance. I just haven't heard many exceptions to unfettered recording and aggregation (these are all I can think of: expectations of privacy in a handful of places, two-party consent for audio recording, actor/model releases, theories of copyrighting building facades).
Instead we're left with only the possibility of regulating the large-scale behavior, which is a political non-starter in the US.
I was confused more about the first question (a school board restricting public schools to those who had been resident one year), because I was trying to reconcile my answer with "well, I know state colleges can charge different rates to in- and out-of-state students" and "well, I can see [this level of] education being a fundamental right in a state constitution, I don't know if being one at the federal level".