News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Finland considers basic income to reform welfare system by kfk on Thursday August 20, 2015 @05:00AM (#10090661)
The problem in those countries is taxes and social contributions. You need to make 10 in order to bring home 5, that kills work, completely. Now the basic income, so basically we want the State to manage even more of the economy. If past experience would prove this effective, then OK, but it just proves the opposite!

Let me do some back of the envelope calculations for you. In Europe we pay around 40% of income tax. On top we pay at least another 8% for pension, which we will never see, and another 8-10% for health insurance, which is not great at all. On top of that, companies have another 30-40% of cost, _on top_ of the bruto salary of an employee in taxes and similar to pay to the state. Bottom line: more than half of your cost to the company goes to the government.

It's just incredibly bad. If you have a 10% unemployment the most effective way to help people is to bring that down to, say, a 3%. That will help most definitely. But for that to happen you need to bring down the cost of labor, which is just too high.

And don't let me start with pension. Europe is basically starving an entire generation, you don't see it now, you will see in 30 years when the young of today will start to go into retirement age. There will be no money to pay a real pension to everybody. You know how much you need to have a very comfortable pension? At a 6% rate, about 500 euro a month for 40 years. That's it, that's all you need. Right now we are paying close to this amount for a public pension, will we see that money? Absolutely not.

Bottom line: they have to fix the economy. That's the only long term solution and the only way to bring people out of unemployment and poverty.

Re:Finland considers basic income to reform welfare system by _petronius on Thursday August 20, 2015 @05:14AM (#10090709)
> If past experience would prove this effective, then OK, but it just proves the opposite!

Can you cite some examples? I'm interested, because I seem to read a lot about how experiments with basic income actually tend to work out very well. (It certainly does in Alaska, although that isn't much money[0], as well as other examples[1] cited in this thread.)

> Europe we pay around 40% of income tax. On top we pay at least another 8% for pension, which we will never see, and another 8-10% for health insurance, which is not great at all. On top of that, companies have another 30-40% of cost, _on top_ of the bruto salary of an employee in taxes and similar to pay to the state.

I don't know how much you earn, or where you work in Europe, but I have never paid this much. Income tax and social security (including NHS contributions, so all my health insurance) in the UK was never more than 30% of my salary. It's about the same for me in Germany right now, if anything a little lower.

Maybe you're in a really wealthy income bracket, though, in which case -- congratulations?

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alaska_Permanent_Fund#Permanen...

[1]: http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/manitoba/1970s-manitoba-povert...

Re:Finland considers basic income to reform welfare system by kfk on Thursday August 20, 2015 @05:57AM (#10090866)
UK is not Europe, in fact you pay less taxes and you actually do get a pension since it's tied to a low taxation fund that belongs to you.

Germany is about 45% once you go over the 45-50k bruto, which is not much if you ask me (rent tends to be 35-40% of your income). Also, note in Germany the company has another 30-40% cost on top of your bruto (they pay the other half of your pension and health insurance, for instance). Don't look just at what you get, but at your overall cost for the company.

Past experience? After World War II public spending has been trending up everywhere (also in US, but more in Europe). What did we get in Europe? Slow growth, huge public debt, 3+ times the unemployment they have in USA, should I continue? The thing is: government is just really, really, bad in any kind of productive spending. Government should take care of the ones in need* and should make clear rules for everybody, that's it, everything else is waste (and we have seen it).

*And let's be clear here: this doesn't mean public housing in the city center. This means giving enough to keep your dignity, which means you need to accept to leave far from the city. Just that people "in need" should be actual people in need, not some privileged class (like in Denmark students get money to study, those are NOT people in need)

Re:Finland considers basic income to reform welfare system by throwaway12309 on Thursday August 20, 2015 @05:53AM (#10090852)
If you are in the UK, 50k a year (above average but honestly, if even remotely close to London, not that much) will bring you a tax bill of around 38% (19k) if you consider employee NHS contributions ( data from http://www.listentotaxman.com/50000? ). So you are already at 38% and you have council tax (probably another 2k or more a year) plus VAT (21% or something?) on stuff you buy. I don't remember other taxes I paid while in the UK but these were the big ones. It isn't hard to get to the end of the year and see that you(+ employer) paid around 50-60% in taxes.

I live in Portugal, and if I consider VAT+income tax+social security contributions (self employed so I pay both parts or approx. 33% in social security) and ignoring other extra taxes (property, road tax, etc) 62% or so of the money I earn goes to the government (this was for 2014, my accountant did the math). I could probably get this lower with some creative accounting I guess.

Re:Finland considers basic income to reform welfare system by IanCal on Thursday August 20, 2015 @11:15AM (#10092363)
> will bring you a tax bill of around 38% (19k) if you consider employee NHS contributions

You're adding on the employer NI contributions there.

Re:Finland considers basic income to reform welfare system by throwaway12309 on Thursday August 20, 2015 @11:34AM (#10092492)
Yes. That was the point of the grandfather post. That on top of that you even have employers contributions. If you add all of that you will get a value that often reaches 50-60%. I've given the example of myself, since I'm self-employed I pay everything, my tax rate is around 60%.
Re:Finland considers basic income to reform welfare system by IanCal on Thursday August 20, 2015 @11:48AM (#10092600)
Ah, if you can still edit it then you might want to change "employee" to "employer" then.

In which case your effective tax rate is ~35% rather than 38%, 36325 / 55780.

My council tax is under £1200/year (and that's for the house, so we should only count half of that for me and half for my wife) and VAT is 20% on some but not all items. Pension contributions bring the tax rate down too, so it gets a bit hard to compare.

Re:Finland considers basic income to reform welfare system by pjc50 on Thursday August 20, 2015 @07:24AM (#10091117)
50k a year (above average)

Not just above average, but in the top decile earning more than 90% of the rest of the country.

Re:Finland considers basic income to reform welfare system by throwaway12309 on Thursday August 20, 2015 @08:44AM (#10091449)
Damn, never thought 50k was that good for UK to be honest. Always thought it was an ok one.

But even using 26.5k (average), we are at close to 30% on taxes on income alone) http://www.listentotaxman.com/26500?

Re:Finland considers basic income to reform welfare system by pjc50 on Thursday August 20, 2015 @09:13AM (#10091580)
It's not fantastic, it's just that the UK is a very unequal country with an expensive property market. 50k gives a comfortable middle-class lifestyle outside London.

If you weren't paying those taxes, how much would you have to pay simply for equivalent health/education/unemployment insurance/pensions cover?

Re:Finland considers basic income to reform welfare system by HappyTypist on Thursday August 20, 2015 @08:06AM (#10091281)
That's the marginal tax rate. It's not your effective tax rate.
Re:Finland considers basic income to reform welfare system by throwaway12309 on Thursday August 20, 2015 @08:36AM (#10091419)
Sorry, can you explain the difference? When I was in the UK that was basically what I paid and never got anything back.
Re:Finland considers basic income to reform welfare system by IanCal on Thursday August 20, 2015 @11:17AM (#10092371)
The marginal tax rate at £50k is actually 42%, just looking at income tax (40%) and NI (2% at that point).
Re:Finland considers basic income to reform welfare system by Radim on Thursday August 20, 2015 @05:36AM (#10090793)
The Czech republic, for example:

For you to bring home 2,000 EUR net, your employer has to dish out 3,740 EUR. That's about 46.5% taxation -- very close to OP's 50%.

(and that's not counting VAT and other consumer taxes, we're talking income only here)

This is not the "high income" bracket either, that attracts an additional "solidarity" income tax.

Like the OP said, nobody really expects to see any pension, and to get good health care, you have to pay private again for that.

Re:Finland considers basic income to reform welfare system by a-saleh on Thursday August 20, 2015 @08:08AM (#10091292)
Well, looking at my payslip, disregarding the fineprint (I have some taxes lower because my wife is a stay-at-home mom) ~40% from what my employer pays for me goes to the state.

This of course includes health insurance, social welfare insurance and income tax.

Re:Finland considers basic income to reform welfare system by Matumio on Thursday August 20, 2015 @05:40AM (#10090813)
The thing with a tax for basic income (as opposed to other taxes) is that the money doesn't go to the government, it goes directly to the people. The government cannot decide how this money is spent, so it's not a "fat government" thing.

And what is this "past experience" you refer to? If you are referring to communism, this is in some sense the very opposite of an unconditional basic income - unconditional means the government cannot tell you what to do (nor can employers, as long as you don't want to own a car, have a nice home, etc.). Yes, "fix the economy". But how? Basic income is actually a proposal how to fix it, I think.

Re:Finland considers basic income to reform welfare system by hliyan on Thursday August 20, 2015 @05:07AM (#10090689)
We should do more back-of-envelope calculations for countries, along the lines of:

   (cost of healthcare + pensions + welfare + welfare bureaucracy + corruption) / population > basic income ?
If the value is greater or equal, basic income makes sense right off the bat.
Re:Finland considers basic income to reform welfare system by pjc50 on Thursday August 20, 2015 @05:21AM (#10090734)
I hope you're not proposing that basic income is a replacement for healthcare? They're two completely different things.
Re:Finland considers basic income to reform welfare system by TeMPOraL on Thursday August 20, 2015 @05:50AM (#10090843)
While of course basic income is not a replacement for healthcare, the health spending cost reduction under such scheme is an interesting topic. A country could probably save a lot on psychiatric hospitals. It's not rare that a person attempts suicide (or looks like they're going to attempt it) because they're poor and in debt, barely holding to a low-paying job; they get put on an observation (during which they'll probably lose their job), stuffed with medication and then thrown back to society at large. The hospitalization itself can cost more than the debt the patient has is worth.

I think such cases are making benefits of BI hard to estimate - because it could eliminate some percentage of costs across so many different aspects of public spending that it's getting hard to keep track of them all.

Re:Finland considers basic income to reform welfare system by notahacker on Thursday August 20, 2015 @09:23AM (#10091641)
Basic income is not going to prevent people from taking on unsustainable debts.

Arguably it's less likely to do so than a conventional bureaucratic, means-tested system, since (i) such systems usually directly subsidise things people tend to get into debt for (housing, education/training, and medical care) and have a more flexible, living-costs-related approach to the size of the subsidies on offer and (ii) predatory lenders can chase the indebted far more aggressively when armed with the knowledge their target has a cash income of at least $xx per month and therefore could easily make the payments if they stopped paying for their house, food and health insurance...

Re:Finland considers basic income to reform welfare system by RobertoG on Thursday August 20, 2015 @07:36AM (#10091167)
And don't forget the reduction in crimes.
Re:Finland considers basic income to reform welfare system by rue on Thursday August 20, 2015 @01:07PM (#10093173)
You always pay for it. The US does have a lower tax rate, for example… but then you pay for health insurance, schooling, etc. etc. that in other places are handled through the higher tax rate.
Re:Finland considers basic income to reform welfare system by ousta on Thursday August 20, 2015 @05:15AM (#10090712)
except for the public pension that is a shameful tool invented to satisfy one generation of privileged people, I disagree with you.

The problem is not the % of income tax. tax is fine if the system works. take a simple example in many european countries education is free. in USA even in a community college, going beyond two year studies will cost you 10K$ per child, then if you do not have a good company insurance it will cost you an arm to insure your family. id rather pay tax to subvention education.

the only problem is that salaries are not going up since the early 00s, tuition costs are going up, consumer goods prices are going up, accomodation price are so crazyly high (especially in cities where there are lot of jobs) that you won't get a house before 30-40 years of debt. Hell people even thought their greatchildren will work two days a week and earn more than them but the sad truth is that the payroll of a qualified worked in today's world will buy you less than a blue collar in the old days. this is the great failure we experiencing right now, tax just did the right thing, they went up, like everything else but our salary.

This is the only thing to fix in the world right now. a company shouldn't make 400K$ profit per employee.