Retraction Watch is close.
You'd need a rogue in each specialty - I'm also guessing that replicating studies doesn't lead to tenure or papers in Nature.
Batman doesn't care about tenure.
Nature editors LOVE controversy though. In my experience they're not really interested in evaluating the long-term substance of a paper as much as if it causes (or pretends to end[1]) a fight right now.
[1] It's really hard to end a fight in 4 pages.
Much narrower focus than dluan's proposal (climate science only); pretty much entirely one-sided (criticizes work supporting the consensus view only, kinda like if Batman only fought the cops). The guy who runs it isn't a scientist (though you could argue that he's a statistician, which might be about as good for dluan's purposes).
So I don't think this really fits dluan's description very well.
We should organize a rogue scientist justice league.
Why batman? Because he had to fight cops just as often as baddies. Not that the current system is necessarily corrupt, but that our current system is almost as blind when it comes to recognition of good science. Our current system is a bit, well, dumb.