Re:Pedants' Favorite Grammar Rules are Probably Fake
by mkr-hn on Wednesday August 19, 2015 @02:42PM
(#10087556)
I have never seen a situation where using a less common spelling or grammar was more distracting than the pedantic tangent it produced.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Pedants' Favorite Grammar Rules are Probably Fake
by dingaling on Wednesday August 19, 2015 @03:24PM
(#10087794)
I've experienced confusion reading corporate documents which contained poor grammar or orthography.
As an example of the latter, based loosely on a real example:
It is preferred to take the server to run-level 1 then to reboot.
So, I telinit 1 followed by shutdown -r now ...?In operational-readiness documents there really must not be any leeway for confusion or ambiguity, yet I've encountered many such examples. The usual retort of 'language evolves!' doesn't hold true in circumstances where a common, unequivocal meaning is required.
You'd think programmers would be aware of that, writing strictly-defined grammar all day long!
Re:Pedants' Favorite Grammar Rules are Probably Fake
by rayiner on Wednesday August 19, 2015 @03:29PM
(#10087830)
That's a fantastic example, thank you.
Re:Pedants' Favorite Grammar Rules are Probably Fake
by schoen on Wednesday August 19, 2015 @02:56PM
(#10087648)
That may be true among native speakers with a roughly similar background, but it's not necessarily true in terms of language varieties and non-native speakers (most likely because the non-native speakers may only recognize one form, or spelling, or construction, or lexeme, and not be able to guess how an alternative is related).
Re:Pedants' Favorite Grammar Rules are Probably Fake
by scrollaway on Wednesday August 19, 2015 @03:18PM
(#10087752)
I have; I see it very regularly, in fact. I'm sure you'd see it more often as well if you worked in translation engineering...