My opinion is that no matter what you call the oligarchy of corporate wealth and public influence that runs the United States, you can't call it fair. The playing field is tilted toward those with power to tilt the playing field. People are profiting from the unfairness in the playing field.
So the moral thing to do is to tilt it back. You don't have to nationalize Nabisco or send millionaires to debtor's prison to improve the situation. But you can tax them disproportionately compared to the poor, and use the money on social programs.
Put another way, above the line of FU money, the marginal value of the millionaire's last dollar is lower. It takes more of their dollars to make a proportionate impact on their income, compared to the impact of the payroll, property, and income taxes on the middle-class salary.
As for social programs, if you give a man enough money to live for a day, he's not going to work for a day. Welfare encourages people to do absolutely nothing.
The rich and their multi-national corporations, evading taxes and lobbying for sweetheart deals from the government, are doing a lot of damage to the American lower class and middle class. I don't have to look far to rip examples from the headlines. The health and drug systems are messed up. The corporate welfare for Wall Street is messed up. Education is messed up. In all cases the poor are disadvantaged to the benefit of the wealthy. They are literally paying taxes for the excesses of powerful corporations and lobbies.
Maybe I used the wrong term, but I consider education a social program. We spend far too little on it. We were hemming and hawing about funding HeadStart not too long ago. We underpay our teachers and then lower our taxes and call it a balanced budget.
There are social programs that are important beyond welfare, so just ignore that one if it is distracting you from the main point.
http://taxprof.typepad.com/taxprof_blog/2007/06/warren-buffe...
I am in pretty good company with this argument I think. We should have a more progressive tax system. There is a lot of room to make it more progressive without damaging incentives to become rich.
There are so many incentives to become rich that it's laughable to say that you could destroy them all through a carefully calculated welfare program.
Ignoring the bit about "fair", that's true, but you don't understand what it means, especially as it relates to "fair".
> So the moral thing to do is to tilt it back.
If it was possible to tilt it back, it wouldn't be tilted. (Reread the first paragraph quoted.)
If you insist on giving govt power, that power will favor those who are the best equipped at tilting govt power to their benefit.
You can't keep them from tilting things in their direction - you can only affect whether there's anything to tilt in their direction.
If you're satisfied with crumbs, keep shoveling power at govt, but stop complaining that others are getting a full meal. If you want to stop them from getting a full meal, you've got to get govt out of the food biz. Yes, you'll lose your crumbs, so you get to make a choice.
Here is a fun bit of trivia.
Q: What was the top personal income tax during the largest expansion of the US middle class on record?
A: It ranged from 92-93%.
That's right. During the post-war boom of the 1950s, the marginal tax rate on income over $1 million/year (in 1950s currency) varied from 92-93%. Oh, and massive increases since the 70s in the numbers of wealthy people, and degree of their wealth have coincided with a long-term decline in the earning power of the middle class.
Of course cause and effect is never provable in cases like this so you can't prove anything from this example, but it certainly doesn't fit with trickle down theory.
But since there is more money to be made telling the rich what they want to hear than what they don't, inconvenient facts like these never get reported in the political debate...
You've heard of three-martini lunches, right? You know that they existed because the cheapest way to drink was to make it a business expense (paid for with pretax dollars) instead of a personal expense (after-tax dollars). At a 92% tax rate, it's 11X as expensive to drink personally as to drink professionally--so the tax policy you laud had the wondrous result of making a decent fraction of American executives half-drunk by noon.
How could this be a win over high taxes? Simple. You would donate an asset that had appreciated for the full value of the asset, which was less than the purchase price. As long as you had a supply of rapidly appreciating assets, your effective tax rate was much lower.
The most popular kind of asset to donate for this purpose was art. The most popular place to donate it was to foundations run by the rich families in question. And appreciation was easy to guarantee when everyone else was following the same strategy.
So the idea is buy 5 Monets for $1 million. A couple of years later donate a million to the family run foundation, the foundation uses that million and buys one Monet from you. You then donate 4 more Monets at the new found valuation of $1 million each. For $2 million in expenses you have now canceled out $5 million in income.
The most lasting legacies of this tax loophole are insanely high art prices and public museums full of extremely expensive art.
Is your solution to move the rich from being rich to being poor? The rich should stay rich. You don't punish the rich to bring the rest of society up.