Re:The Ashley Madison Database Was Leaked
by PhasmaFelis on Wednesday August 19, 2015 @11:06PM
(#10089860)
If we say that it is never acceptable for vigilantes to release illegally-obtained information, then shouldn't we also be decrying Ed Snowden and Chelsea Manning? Their dumps certainly contained unpleasant stuff that could be traced back to individuals. There's got to be a line somewhere, even if it's not at Ashley Madison specifically.
Re:The Ashley Madison Database Was Leaked
by saiya-jin on Thursday August 20, 2015 @08:07AM
(#10091284)
the sad thing is, both of you are right, and no matter what I do, I cannot decide who is "more right". strange times indeed :)
Re:The Ashley Madison Database Was Leaked
by fweespeech on Thursday August 20, 2015 @12:15PM
(#10092783)
You'll notice I left out an exception for revolution / rebelling against the government. If you get to the point you need vigilantes to fight the government, well, yeah.
In the context of a private company, yes, its never acceptable.
Yes. The legal system is responsible for bringing criminals to justice. The system maybe imperfect but its better than vigilantes with a deeply held, righteous cause who honestly believe their targets to be evil. Fanatics of all stripes see themselves in that light and that kind of thinking is extremely dangerous. In truth, it should only be used in the event a blood revolution is the only option available to the citizenry.