Re:Brian Kernighan on C [video]
by MichaelGG on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @08:04PM
(#10082965)
Really? I like C but I'm not sure it's beautiful, compared to a LISP or some sort of ML. And my limited experience says that C programs involve a ton of boilerplate code dealing with copying bytes around. Every time I see a loop doing a series of if/elseifs to parse command line options, I think this is very much not beautiful.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Brian Kernighan on C [video]
by vezzy-fnord on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @09:46PM
(#10083282)
Lisp and ML represent quite different models of computation.
For a register machine, C can be pretty beautiful.
It's funny you talk about parsing command line options. Plan 9 solved that problem well with the arg(2) macros. [1]
In fact, Plan 9 in general is a premier example of really clean and elegant ANSI C-compatible code. [2]
[1] http://man.cat-v.org/plan_9/2/arg
[2] e.g. https://github.com/0intro/plan9/blob/master/sys/src/libndb/n...
Read the V6 Unix sources. They are seriously pretty. A file system in maybe a thousand lines of code. A scheduler and swap manager, a TTY layer, and device drivers with nearly no waste. You can read the code in an afternoon and understand it and make changes to it.
Even in crusty pre-ANSI C, it's very elegant stuff.
(Then I look at the Bourne shell sources and weep. It's like the author of that was in denial of everything that made C a decent language and wanted desperately to be doing something else)
How would XV6 compare to V6 for code elegance? XV6 being a reimplementation, of V6 Unix with ANSI C and targeting X86 instead. But was done by different people as far as I know.
>Really? I like C but I'm not sure it's beautiful, compared to a LISP or some sort of ML.
It's another sense of beauty, the one of talking almost directy to the machine, with few abstractions, and few wastage.