News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Corn Wars by cbd1984 on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @04:30PM (#10081961)
> GM crops being the only viable food source on the planet.

They already are.

Or do you think maize and the current varieties of wheat, fruit trees, rice, and so on are natural?

Re:Corn Wars by tomp on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @05:36PM (#10082375)
They've been selected by humans for millennia, but they are not GM in the usual sense of the world.
Re:Corn Wars by vonmoltke on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @06:30PM (#10082642)
The "usual sense of the word" is a politically charged and unscientific one. There is nothing special about merging genes in a lab versus merging genes by forcing plants to grow together in a field. The end result is the same: a hybrid plant.
Re:Corn Wars by tomp on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @06:37PM (#10082673)
I don't find this argument convincing. That's like saying, there's nothing special in the Manhattan project, we could as well try putting different combinations of materials in the same room and wait for them to randomly recombine into an atomic bomb.
Re:Corn Wars by inversionOf on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @06:43PM (#10082690)
The article specifically talks about taking genes from bacteria (tolerance to certain chemicals, for instance) and splicing it into crops. This isn't quite the same as cross pollination.
Re:Corn Wars by scott_s on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @06:14PM (#10082567)
From the submitted article: "Today, it’s estimated that 92 percent of American corn and 94 percent of American soybeans are GMOs, almost all of it produced by Monsanto or DuPont Pioneer, and again, nearly half of the seed sold globally."
Re:Corn Wars by makomk on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @06:35PM (#10082664)
Those weren't patentable in the same way. (Selectively bred varieties were covered by plant patents and plant breeder's rights, but those are a lot narrower in scope than the utility patents that apply to GM crops.)
Re:Corn Wars by Obi_Juan_Kenobi on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @07:02PM (#10082776)
Can you elaborate on the difference between plant patents and utility patents which you feel is harmful?

Plant patents last for 20 to 30 years and are quite robust. The main exemptions are for seed saving (irrelevant for hybrid crops), use as a progenitor (irrelevant to transgenics which vary at a single locus), and for compulsory licensing.

With the exception of the latter issue, these aspects have no bearing on GM. Seed saving would be an issue in crops that typically are not grown as hybrids. However, utility patents are shorter in duration and require disclosure. There's nothing stopping someone else from going out to find germplasm with a similar trait and generating their own construct. With advances in technology, this becomes ever easier to do. The supreme court's ruling on the BRCA genes makes it quite clear that this is permissible and would not be restricted by a utility patent.

In my estimation, a utility patent is less restrictive.

Re:Corn Wars by makomk on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @07:21PM (#10082842)
You yourself point out an important difference - plant patents cover a single variety, utility patents cover every variety with a particular gene, no matter how it got there. (And the ability to save seeds is not "irrelevant for hybrid crops" - yes, you lose most of the benefits of having a hybrid variety, but farmers do it anyway because for some plantings the cost saving is worth the loss in yield.)

What's more, there's also quite a nasty patent thicket covering the techniques used in creating GM crops, so you can't just dodge the problem by going out and creating your own GM plant. It's one of the reasons golden rice was doomed to fail - it requires patent licenses from something like 30 companies because of the techniques it uses, including all the big biotech corps. Its creator managed to get heavily restricted free licenses for them because it made a good PR weapon against anti-GMO activists (his explanation), but the conditions make it pretty much useless. Only subsistence farmers or countries which can't grow enough calories to feed their population are legally allowed to grow it, and out of the latter I think only the Philippines even has the right climate to grow rice.

Re:Corn Wars by sampo on Wednesday August 19, 2015 @07:06AM (#10084692)
Golder Rice 2 was developed in 2005, so whatever patents it contains, they will cease in 2025 at the latest.