News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sugar: The Bitter Truth (UCSF lecture) by Tichy on Monday December 21, 2009 @11:21AM (#1008037)
I think he admitted himself to cherry picking somewhere - everybody would be cherry picking... In principle I have nothing against "more" references, however, in that book it is so much that it becomes once more impossible to check up on it. You can only give in to the sheer number and size of references. Personally I find that a bit unsatisfying and unnecessary. I would have preferred concentration on a few core points.
Re:Sugar: The Bitter Truth (UCSF lecture) by gregwebs on Monday December 21, 2009 @02:49PM (#1008457)
Good point. Maybe he should have had a couple concentrated chapters at the beginning of the book, and then used the rest as a historical reference. If you want to check up on his arguments against the current dogma just check on his analyses of the the few high quality large scale studies that have been done.