News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US Patent 9085897: Space elevator by logfromblammo on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @10:53AM (#10079499)
I often see this on HN: ideas are nothing; execution is everything.

I don't think a model is necessary for a patent application, but some check on bullshit is necessary. If you are granted the patent, and following the instructions in it does not yield a working device--or if the instructions cannot be followed, because they require an impossibility or something that does not yet exist--that should be grounds for immediate disqualification.

There has to be some way to encourage "this is how you do it" over "so I have this really cool idea that I think is worth lots of money".

Re:US Patent 9085897: Space elevator by rayiner on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @12:08PM (#10079955)
> I often see this on HN: ideas are nothing; execution is everything.

Counterexample: designing TCP/IP was an expensive, R&D-intensive process, but it's pretty easy to write a TCP/IP stack given the RFCs.