Re:DIY Tractor Repair Runs Afoul Of Copyright Law
by joesmo on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @12:07PM
(#10079947)
If he could actually fix the software, it's possible he could break the digital lock to get there. And it would be illegal. So what? At this point, it should be no surprise to anyone that just about everyone in America needs to break the law on a daily basis to live. It's not news. Just don't get caught. Honestly, I'm tired of reading articles about yet another everyday activity that's illegal in the land of the free. If a solution was proposed, I'd be all ears, but as it stands, no one has a workable solution for the abomination our legal and penal systems have become. Otherwise, this is just another example of freedom amongst too many to count. (NOTE: Some sarcasm present above.)
Re:DIY Tractor Repair Runs Afoul Of Copyright Law
by stcredzero on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @12:22PM
(#10080075)
What's keeping this from being a campaign issue? The DMCA is a badly thought-out pernicious law. It interferes with academic and research work. It interferes with the independent DIY spirit of people like this farmer. It means we effectively do not fully own our own stuff that we've paid for. Why isn't this a campaign issue? Can someone paint me a picture concerning demographics, campaign finance, backed up with data?
Re:DIY Tractor Repair Runs Afoul Of Copyright Law
by Phlarp on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @01:13PM
(#10080508)
Campaign issues get made out of topics or concerns that statistically relevant numbers of people consider a good enough reason alone to vote for someone, these are called "single issue voters" -- Abortion is generally the easiest example as both parties use either side of the debate as a single issue lightning rod and large numbers of people will ignore all other positions any given politician advocates for or against, just so long as they are unwavering on their commitment to protect [unborn life|a woman's right to choose]. Previously gay marriage was a similar issue, although that particular topic is mostly moot at this point, at least as far as American politics are concerned.
Copyright reform, along with corporate tax reform, both get rolled into more general economic concerns, the most prominent of which will always be unemployment. Which rarely becomes a serious issue in campaigns unless the jobless rate is particularly high.
Rand Paul and Chris Christie are both attempting to make state surveillance a "single issue voter" concern, I imagine this would be the best place to attempt to slip copyright concerns in alongside-- however, I doubt wiretapping or copyright is a big enough issue to become a real driver of campaigns the way abortion is.
Re:DIY Tractor Repair Runs Afoul Of Copyright Law
by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @01:27PM
(#10080625)
Given how much the Iowa primary matters, and how much farming there is in Iowa, there may be some leverage there to make it an issue on the national stage...
Re:DIY Tractor Repair Runs Afoul Of Copyright Law
by ArkyBeagle on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @01:02PM
(#10080425)
But for something like a tractor, the firmware is part of the machine. If you could change it, you might get it to say, break EPA regs for carbon emissions or otherwise behave in an unsafe manner.
With all due respect, it sounds like they guy just doesn't wanna pay a tech to come out ( whether the reason is cost in dollars or cost in time ) . I don't blame him at all, but these things have to be done in a controlled manner.
And strictly speaking, the thing shouldn't be broken in the first place. I won't go as far as to say engine monitors should never have any problems upon release, but it's close to that. This sort of thing should be close to "C.A.R. Tony Hoare complete" and very nearly provably correct.
Re:DIY Tractor Repair Runs Afoul Of Copyright Law
by wvenable on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @01:12PM
(#10080501)
> If you could change it, you might get it to say, break EPA regs for carbon emissions or otherwise behave in an unsafe manner.
People have been doing this for a hundred years. You could always change a machine to make it unsafe. This has only become illegal now that software is involved.
The idea that people are no longer able to fix their own equipment, or that it has to be done "in a controlled manner", is a new idea. As a society, we've been heading down this slippery slope for a long time and it's now to the point that your opinion isn't outside of the norm even on a site called Hacker News.
It's overall a lack of trust for one's fellow man. Here you are arguing about farmers breaking EPA regs or making their own equipment unsafe. When farmers are arguing to be able to make their equipment work when it needs to work using their own skills.
Re:DIY Tractor Repair Runs Afoul Of Copyright Law
by SolarNet on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @01:14PM
(#10080524)
Regulations like the EPA regulations typically only apply to selling the hardware. If you own and operate it on your own property and never sell it to anyone you have a lot more leeway.
Re:DIY Tractor Repair Runs Afoul Of Copyright Law
by gcb0 on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @11:57AM
(#10079884)
just like with cars bought by companies and rentals, construction and farm machines are bought mostly with the warranty in mind.
just like in software, for every one nerd that wants to fix things themselves, there are millions who do not. and those folks don't even change the oil to not lose warranty. and newer models even phone home (to the dealer!) when the engine is being abused. and it's actually sold to the buyer as a feature, because the phone home system can be used in case of theft.
do you rater sell one hactor or a million tractors?
Re:DIY Tractor Repair Runs Afoul Of Copyright Law
by cconcepts on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @12:13PM
(#10080002)
I would see the average farmer as a little different to your average car/cellphone user. As the article points out, getting things fixed quick and the ability to do it yourself for cheap are critical factors for many farmers and an integral part of their daily lives.
I've worked on many farms and always spent a large chunk of my time fixing a tractor or other farm implement.
Re:DIY Tractor Repair Runs Afoul Of Copyright Law
by rebootthesystem on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @12:06PM
(#10079938)
This sort of thing isn't unique to tractors. Our Haas Vertical Machining Centers are great machines while, at the same time, being grotesque examples of "no user serviceable parts inside".
This is ridiculous when you consider we have a group of electrical and software engineers with 20 to 30 years of experience in just about all aspects of technology, including real time embedded systems and robotics. In many ways we are far more qualified to support these machines than the techs they send over. I mean, we could actually design these machines from scratch.
No, you can't get tech manuals. No, you can't have access to internals. Yes, there are a bunch of secret codes and you can't have them. And, yes, you will pay $1,000 (or whatever it was, I forget) for an additional 16 MEGA bytes of memory.
No, we are not eager to jump into a $200K machine to fiddle with it. We are busy enough with our own work. It's about simple things. When a machine goes down for some silly reason it'd be nice to be able to diagnose and get it back up and running rather than waste a bunch of time waiting for a tech who is going to enter a few secret codes to do the same. I've seen it done a bunch of times and it is infuriating.
I also do understand that the typical big iron CNC user doesn't have our profile. We are not a production shop. We have a well stocked CNC shop for prototyping product designs, just like we have pick-and-place capabilities in house. We are a product engineering firm staffed with highly experienced engineers, not a machine shop.
I can see a company like Haas deciding "no way we are giving access to internals to machinist". I get it. Yet, at the same time, they have no provisions for opening the doors to more capable users. I don't even think they have a class you can take to become qualified. Perhaps the tractor industry is similar?
Re:DIY Tractor Repair Runs Afoul Of Copyright Law
by foofoo55 on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @11:46AM
(#10079805)
How does the DMCA stop a tractor owner from replacing a faulty sensor, engine part, or a drive belt? The article implies that the DMCA stops the farmer from fixing even mechanical components.
Re:DIY Tractor Repair Runs Afoul Of Copyright Law
by emeraldd on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @12:06PM
(#10079944)
The problem is going to be getting enough information out of the machine to actually diagnose what the underlying problem is. With the belt story, there was nothing wrong with the belt but the computer thought there was. He could have thrown a new belt on it (i.e. throwing money at the problem and try again) but that wouldn't have fixed the problem. Heck, that might have been the first thing he tried. Diagnosing an issue by replacing part after part along the problem chain takes time and gets expensive fast making it impractical for anything really serious.
Re:DIY Tractor Repair Runs Afoul Of Copyright Law
by joezydeco on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @12:23PM
(#10080079)
But it's not like the farmer is trying to retune the internal tables of his engine controller or override some kind of operation mode. He just wants to get the fault code out of the system.
It seems like there's plenty of room for a middle ground here. Deere certainly could have opened up some kind of way for owners to get fault codes out of the system, at least for things that are user-replaceable. Hell, the UI should at least put up that message ("CHECK ENGINE OIL", "BELT BROKEN", etc). But then the owner might not buy the replacement part from Deere, right? Perhaps that's the real motivation here.
Re:DIY Tractor Repair Runs Afoul Of Copyright Law
by chinpokomon on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @12:43PM
(#10080259)
But the replacement part and send out the field service technician. Deere wants to own the service contract.
As another example, I had a check engine light on my car. It was ~$500 to check the code fault and replace a sensor. If I had my own access to those codes, I could have done the work myself for a fraction of the cost, but the car manufacturer knows that I'm limited in my options. If I want to renew my car tabs, I'll have to pay them and their service technician to do the work. It's a racket.
Re:DIY Tractor Repair Runs Afoul Of Copyright Law
by sokoloff on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @01:03PM
(#10080428)
That's the reason for the openness of the basic ODB-II protocol. You can buy a sub-$100 code reader that can read all the basic powertrain codes and can reset the MIL.
That and 2 minutes of Googling will point you in the right direction generally.
My cars haven't seen the inside of a dealer's service bay in over 10 years, other than for warranty or recall work.
Re:DIY Tractor Repair Runs Afoul Of Copyright Law
by joezydeco on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @01:34PM
(#10080703)
But OBD-II only has to (by law) provide certain information to the reader, mostly to do with emissions control.
If you own a BMW, for example, the detailed diagnostic information for the rest of the car is sitting on their MODBUS, which is only readable with a very expensive tool and software sold only to BMW dealers.
Re:DIY Tractor Repair Runs Afoul Of Copyright Law
by sokoloff on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @02:36PM
(#10081214)
Yes, but those systems are not involved in the grandparent post's problem of a MIL ("check engine light") preventing the car from passing inspection.
Whether or not you can service the rest of the car in a DIY or third-party fashion is a commercial concern, not a regulatory concern. I think BMW makes fine cars, but their anti-DIY stance is why I won't own one. (Porsche, Mercedes, and the VW group are more DIY friendly, though still not totally.)
Re:DIY Tractor Repair Runs Afoul Of Copyright Law
by fnordfnordfnord on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @02:24PM
(#10081117)
I think you mean CANBus. You can purchase very inexpensive CAN transceivers, but you're on your own figuring out the messages. MODBUS is an industrial automation relic (but like all things in ind. automation, still very popular), and not limited to a particular physical layer.
Re:DIY Tractor Repair Runs Afoul Of Copyright Law
by foofoo55 on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @12:44PM
(#10080263)
A customer with a fancy new $2M machine couldn't easily diagnose problems in the field because the LCD on the machine would only show fault numbers or classes of faults. So they paid me to make an additional display which tied into the machine and showed detailed plain-English status and error messages. Very tedious work, and only slightly difficult to ensure false messages are not posted. I always wonder if the original programmers get lazy at implementing such details ("the user can always read the manual") or they run out of time due to shipping deadlines. Would a company like JD really keep things cryptic on purpose?
Re:DIY Tractor Repair Runs Afoul Of Copyright Law
by joezydeco on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @01:37PM
(#10080729)
Having worked with a company similar to Deere in the construction/Ag sector they pretty much run like any other automotive company. Very long schedules to engineer and deploy electronics, sometimes on the order of 4-5 years for a next generation system. If something like this was left out, it was left out by specification (or lack thereof) and not a last-minute-rush omission.
Re:DIY Tractor Repair Runs Afoul Of Copyright Law
by stcredzero on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @12:52PM
(#10080342)
My 1990 (if I recall the year correctly) Honda CRX had a little LED readout with the fault code. "Prosumer" and bonafide professionals should be insisting on this sort of capability -- we should "own" the operating data in our stuff, even if we don't have the software license. We should insist that access be available, for no extra cost and refuse to buy otherwise.
Re:DIY Tractor Repair Runs Afoul Of Copyright Law
by bri3d on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @12:01PM
(#10079902)
The sensors and engine parts are often "coded" in a way that requires software access to replace - either because they require some sort of calibration to operate, or because they literally have a burned-in serial number which the software checks for a match.
Re:DIY Tractor Repair Runs Afoul Of Copyright Law
by foofoo55 on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @12:27PM
(#10080110)
I write control software for low-volume off-highway machinery, and I have never seen sensor serial numbers used in this manner. Calibration yes, serial numbers no. And lack of calibration just puts things off a bit, but doesn't prevent operation. I suppose if they use CAN communications for their sensors instead of analog then a sensor might need the address set up and possibly the calibration values loaded, but off-the-shelf replacement parts are usually factory-set to the correct address & internal calibration. And I can see how the manufacturer could disable the machine until certain latched fault codes are cleared by a factory tech.
I would love to see an analysis of modern machine downtime versus equivalent machines from 10 and 20 years ago.
Just imagine if the likes of JD puts all tractor operating parameters in a cloud system, and requires not just Internet access but a login to operate the machine. Not unlike a certain startup from a couple years ago that sold hardware (was it home security?) that required constant cloud access to operate.
I have friends with skid-steers who beg me to replace the keyless electronic start & monitoring console with a simple electro-mechanical key and analog gauges.
Re:DIY Tractor Repair Runs Afoul Of Copyright Law
by Zikes on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @11:26AM
(#10079682)
Wasn't it last year that the Library of Congress made cell phones an exemption? There was a big hullabaloo about jailbreaking being illegal up to that point.
Re:DIY Tractor Repair Runs Afoul Of Copyright Law
by Zikes on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @11:37AM
(#10079754)
Ah, so it's been longer than I thought.
Well, it'll be interesting to see what happens if jailbreakers get that rug pulled out from under them. It might drive a long-overdue reform of the DMCA.
Re:DIY Tractor Repair Runs Afoul Of Copyright Law
by gcb0 on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @12:00PM
(#10079896)
coinciding with Motorola and others (well, htc broke...) quitting offers on "developer" models.
make me think if the ill supported dev models were not just a way to try to corrupt that. "he can't jail break that one because it's not the Dev model. if they wanted to, they should have bought that one"
Re:DIY Tractor Repair Runs Afoul Of Copyright Law
by lumberjack on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @01:13PM
(#10080514)
Since John Deere is so widespread in the US, the farmers could open a cooperative dealership if only to get access to the proprietary tools. Then I guess they'd have to file an anti-trust case against John Deere to force them to hand over the tools but you cannot achieve much without legal action these days.
Re:DIY Tractor Repair Runs Afoul Of Copyright Law
by zardo on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @12:47PM
(#10080297)
Engine manufacturers are required to make emission critical electronics tamper resistant. Opening up anything that effects emissions is a violation of the clean air act.
Vehicle control code is a separate deal, but liability is a nightmare. If the tractor malfunctions and kills someone, who's fault was it?
Re:DIY Tractor Repair Runs Afoul Of Copyright Law
by scotch_drinker on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @12:04PM
(#10079928)
Except that the generic consumer in this case is actually very specialized and the market is very illiquid. There are only so many types of tractors you can buy and I would imagine all of them have the software since it "improves" efficiency.
There is an excellent book called "Shop Class as Soulcraft: An Inquiry Into The Value Of Work" that examines this move towards things in our life that we can no longer fix on our own. You can't change the oil in fancy cars because they have no dipsticks. You can't fix the tractor because it has proprietary software. You can't jail break your phone because it's illegal (or was and could be again). Etc, etc. We are rapidly getting to the point where no one, not even the historically self-reliant, can fix the things they supposedly own. We don't actually "own" these things anymore, we are just renting them. Or best case, we have them on loan until we throw them out for something newer.
Whether all this is an improvement is a matter of discussion but there seems to be no doubt that the concept of "ownership" is rapidly changing.
Re:DIY Tractor Repair Runs Afoul Of Copyright Law
by digi_owl on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @12:17PM
(#10080029)
Copyright, and its close relative the patent, are all about extracting rent.
The trick here is not the tractor itself, but the IP behind it. The tractor, or something like it, may well be produced over and over, but the IP contained within is rented out after being created once.
Re:DIY Tractor Repair Runs Afoul Of Copyright Law
by rayiner on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @01:06PM
(#10080452)
That's irrelevant here, where the subject of the transaction is the tractor itself, and the IP is wholly incidental to that. The manufacturer could achieve the same effect with a contractual provision that said: "you won't service the tractor yourself" (and probably does have such a contractual provision).
Copyright reform, along with corporate tax reform, both get rolled into more general economic concerns, the most prominent of which will always be unemployment. Which rarely becomes a serious issue in campaigns unless the jobless rate is particularly high.
Rand Paul and Chris Christie are both attempting to make state surveillance a "single issue voter" concern, I imagine this would be the best place to attempt to slip copyright concerns in alongside-- however, I doubt wiretapping or copyright is a big enough issue to become a real driver of campaigns the way abortion is.
Money. Sony/Ford/JohnDeere has more of it than you or I.
With all due respect, it sounds like they guy just doesn't wanna pay a tech to come out ( whether the reason is cost in dollars or cost in time ) . I don't blame him at all, but these things have to be done in a controlled manner.
And strictly speaking, the thing shouldn't be broken in the first place. I won't go as far as to say engine monitors should never have any problems upon release, but it's close to that. This sort of thing should be close to "C.A.R. Tony Hoare complete" and very nearly provably correct.
People have been doing this for a hundred years. You could always change a machine to make it unsafe. This has only become illegal now that software is involved.
The idea that people are no longer able to fix their own equipment, or that it has to be done "in a controlled manner", is a new idea. As a society, we've been heading down this slippery slope for a long time and it's now to the point that your opinion isn't outside of the norm even on a site called Hacker News.
It's overall a lack of trust for one's fellow man. Here you are arguing about farmers breaking EPA regs or making their own equipment unsafe. When farmers are arguing to be able to make their equipment work when it needs to work using their own skills.
It is a new idea. And the irony of me saying this on Hacker News is thick as cheese.
I do have to wonder how a farmer can "fix" code for an engine status display. If it's just "broken" broken, then you'd need parts anyway.
EDIT: I've got patent dibs on the name "Hactor"
just like in software, for every one nerd that wants to fix things themselves, there are millions who do not. and those folks don't even change the oil to not lose warranty. and newer models even phone home (to the dealer!) when the engine is being abused. and it's actually sold to the buyer as a feature, because the phone home system can be used in case of theft.
do you rater sell one hactor or a million tractors?
I've worked on many farms and always spent a large chunk of my time fixing a tractor or other farm implement.
they mostly buy used. and couldn't care less about drm or dealer visits.
now if you have over a dozen they will send people in less than 4h and invite you to expensive cocktail parties every quarter
- http://www.ted.com/talks/marcin_jakubowski?language=en
- http://opensourceecology.org/portfolio/tractor/
This is ridiculous when you consider we have a group of electrical and software engineers with 20 to 30 years of experience in just about all aspects of technology, including real time embedded systems and robotics. In many ways we are far more qualified to support these machines than the techs they send over. I mean, we could actually design these machines from scratch.
No, you can't get tech manuals. No, you can't have access to internals. Yes, there are a bunch of secret codes and you can't have them. And, yes, you will pay $1,000 (or whatever it was, I forget) for an additional 16 MEGA bytes of memory.
No, we are not eager to jump into a $200K machine to fiddle with it. We are busy enough with our own work. It's about simple things. When a machine goes down for some silly reason it'd be nice to be able to diagnose and get it back up and running rather than waste a bunch of time waiting for a tech who is going to enter a few secret codes to do the same. I've seen it done a bunch of times and it is infuriating.
I also do understand that the typical big iron CNC user doesn't have our profile. We are not a production shop. We have a well stocked CNC shop for prototyping product designs, just like we have pick-and-place capabilities in house. We are a product engineering firm staffed with highly experienced engineers, not a machine shop.
I can see a company like Haas deciding "no way we are giving access to internals to machinist". I get it. Yet, at the same time, they have no provisions for opening the doors to more capable users. I don't even think they have a class you can take to become qualified. Perhaps the tractor industry is similar?
It seems like there's plenty of room for a middle ground here. Deere certainly could have opened up some kind of way for owners to get fault codes out of the system, at least for things that are user-replaceable. Hell, the UI should at least put up that message ("CHECK ENGINE OIL", "BELT BROKEN", etc). But then the owner might not buy the replacement part from Deere, right? Perhaps that's the real motivation here.
As another example, I had a check engine light on my car. It was ~$500 to check the code fault and replace a sensor. If I had my own access to those codes, I could have done the work myself for a fraction of the cost, but the car manufacturer knows that I'm limited in my options. If I want to renew my car tabs, I'll have to pay them and their service technician to do the work. It's a racket.
That and 2 minutes of Googling will point you in the right direction generally.
My cars haven't seen the inside of a dealer's service bay in over 10 years, other than for warranty or recall work.
If you own a BMW, for example, the detailed diagnostic information for the rest of the car is sitting on their MODBUS, which is only readable with a very expensive tool and software sold only to BMW dealers.
Whether or not you can service the rest of the car in a DIY or third-party fashion is a commercial concern, not a regulatory concern. I think BMW makes fine cars, but their anti-DIY stance is why I won't own one. (Porsche, Mercedes, and the VW group are more DIY friendly, though still not totally.)
You can get OBD2 readers for not very much money (<$20), which would have let you read the code.
It's this, or else it was never in the scope of work to begin with.
>Would a company like JD really keep things cryptic on purpose?
Yes. It serves their interests well.
I would love to see an analysis of modern machine downtime versus equivalent machines from 10 and 20 years ago.
Just imagine if the likes of JD puts all tractor operating parameters in a cloud system, and requires not just Internet access but a login to operate the machine. Not unlike a certain startup from a couple years ago that sold hardware (was it home security?) that required constant cloud access to operate.
I have friends with skid-steers who beg me to replace the keyless electronic start & monitoring console with a simple electro-mechanical key and analog gauges.
Well, it'll be interesting to see what happens if jailbreakers get that rug pulled out from under them. It might drive a long-overdue reform of the DMCA.
make me think if the ill supported dev models were not just a way to try to corrupt that. "he can't jail break that one because it's not the Dev model. if they wanted to, they should have bought that one"
Vehicle control code is a separate deal, but liability is a nightmare. If the tractor malfunctions and kills someone, who's fault was it?
There is an excellent book called "Shop Class as Soulcraft: An Inquiry Into The Value Of Work" that examines this move towards things in our life that we can no longer fix on our own. You can't change the oil in fancy cars because they have no dipsticks. You can't fix the tractor because it has proprietary software. You can't jail break your phone because it's illegal (or was and could be again). Etc, etc. We are rapidly getting to the point where no one, not even the historically self-reliant, can fix the things they supposedly own. We don't actually "own" these things anymore, we are just renting them. Or best case, we have them on loan until we throw them out for something newer.
Whether all this is an improvement is a matter of discussion but there seems to be no doubt that the concept of "ownership" is rapidly changing.
This seems to be a trend across even more of society than just products with DMCA-laden micro-controllers.
Perhaps the focus of open source and hacktivism should be in an alternative ecosystem for micro-controllers?
The trick here is not the tractor itself, but the IP behind it. The tractor, or something like it, may well be produced over and over, but the IP contained within is rented out after being created once.