Speak for yourself. I've worked in finance for more than 10 years and like my job. Most of the time I work on interesting problems with smart people under good work conditions, and get paid well to do it.
It helps that I work in an area of finance I feel does have positive social value, although doing work I am good at and find interesting is more of a motivation.
In 2007 key players (mortgage originators, banks, ratings agencies, governmental agencies and investors) only had incentives for mortgage prices to go up. It was hard to bet on prices going down, and even when you could it was hard to get enough information to realize how overpriced mortgages were. This poorly functioning market resulted in disaster.
The stock market has much more information available, and it is usually easy to bet against prices that are too high. The collective intelligence of many smart people determines stock prices using money, a powerful incentive to get things right. This results in a liquid, well-functioning market with many positive social effects. Google exists today in part because an angel investor knew that if the company succeeded there were well-functioning public markets to sell into. While it's popular to say that the stock market influences company behavior negatively, and causes "short-termism", I believe the opposite:
http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2015/08/24/the-short-termi...
The market often imposes discipline on managers who would otherwise run companies for their own benefit at the expense of everyone else.
You can tell a similar story for the social benefits of lending money, and the importance of doing it well.
The world has seen a vast improvement in wealth, health, education, and safety in the last 100 years, and I think a large contributor is a financial system that has enabled and rewarded socially useful enterprises.
As I said, this is an oversimplification, and a lot of smart people completely disagree. I don't deny that there are jobs in finance that seem to me to be pure rent-seeking, with negative social value. However, I think that overall the system works well, and that the work I do makes it run a tiny bit better.
Depends on how beautiful you find the numbers you're using to get there.
edit
To clarify, there are personalities that derive quite a bit of pleasure from the puzzle without much regard for the picture it makes in the end.
But as others say it's totally his decision. He's clearly smart and fortunate; I'm happy for him.
Ehhhh, Black–Scholes vs. Navier-Stokes. Six of one, half a dozen of another...
I've been working as a programmer for the last 5-6 years, and I strongly disagree.
Pixar, Google and Two Sigma, and many similar companies in these industries, are ultimately absolutely pointless and empty. Entertainment (distraction), ads (mind pollution), and arbitrage (stealing) is essentially what they do. Working for any of them will become mind-numbingly boring and damaging to the soul very soon.
There are only two things that keep me motivated; (1) hard problems, and (2) money. (1) are hard to come by, most of my time I spend dealing with stupid problems caused by stupid people. (2) is why I work on pointless problems, the more I earn the sooner I can retire to do something actually useful.
Therefore, I think that working for a hedge fund in a money-generating role can do wonders to one's motivation; the better you are, the more you earn. Not many roles, in general and in software development, offer such direct payoff.
The revenue model and the incentives it creates for certain aspects of the above creations is not ideal, I agree, but that's a separate issue than these companies' creations are absolutely pointless. It is a valid reason to not work for them though, as you are just advancing their advertisement driven business.
Do you honestly only see art's place in human society and our history as nothing more than distraction? Do you honestly believe Google only has done mind pollution to the world? Are all financial services nothing but stealing to you.
Your above statement only shows one thing: you are either extremely ignorant or you are extremely sanctimonious, probably both.
You are fully entitled to your own opinions, but you don't have the right to belittle other people's passion and interest.
To be honest what motivates you seems like nothing but vanity to me, good for you I guess, but I'm glad there are lots of people who don't share the same mind set.
I'm curious what you consider "worthwhile" endeavors, both personally (personal satisfaction/happiness) and globally (something society should strive for), and how or if they differ.
http://www.today.com/id/31448115/ns/today-today_entertainmen...
Plus, it's Google[X], which is a subsidiary of alphabet. So nitpick that if you want to nitpick. It still wouldn't be called Alphabet.
Also you still apply to Google for the job.
You've never bought something for less than it's worth or sold something for more than it's worth?
I like, perhaps love Pixar, but I'm not sure if I'd call, what are essentially kids movies, "beautiful things." Especially when a lot of the art design is fairly formulaic (see the Pixar face: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/film/inside-out/disney-pixar-char...) Story-wise there are maybe four kid movie plots that get recycled as well. I could see a very smart and creative person feeling hamstrung in such an environment. Especially considering as kids movies they cannot explore adult topics and will always be fairly limited in scope.
I also dislike that idea that automation, code, math, finance, etc can't be beautiful on its own. I'd love it if we could sell young people on the beauty of these things. Getting things like this right can be incredibly satisfying. I know its a hard sell, but most thing worthwhile are. Honestly, the worlds need less impassioned animators and comic book artists and rock stars. It needs more people able to solve hard problems, sometimes in fairly unsexy ways to an audience that may not even understand what the problem was or how difficult it was to solve. Entertainment shouldn't be a brain drain from other fields.
> Especially considering as kids movies they cannot explore adult topics and will always be fairly limited in scope.
I disagree. I've seen many masterful "childrens" movies that have done masterful jobs at exploring adult concepts, as long as by "adult" you don't just mean sexuality. While childrens' movies may be constrained on some axis, they are often freer on others. Additionally, there is the chance to speak to people that wouldn't normally go to a movie about some of these adult messages, or to reach them when they aren't expecting it and are less cynical. Who goes to see an animated film about a family of super heroes to see a touching rendition of mid-life crisis?
That said, I do think there are a lot of creative frontiers to be explored with material suitable for older audiences only. If they wanted, Pixar could make the most terrifying psychological horror known to Man, or a tragedy so heart-wrenching that everyone heads to the bars afterward.
If he wants advice from someone in finance, I'd steer him towards Pixar. The math might be harder and the prestige may be greater at the hedge fund, but making beautiful things is inherently satisfying. Sweating to make a big number get a bit bigger isn't good for the soul in the long term.