To me, Rust is easier to use than both Go and Haskell. Regarding Go, I don't like its inexpressiveness.
Regarding Haskell, I'm tired of its various aspects like
1. Insane defaults. `String` being `[Char]`, `-Wall` is almost always necessary, no record types, `import` imports all names by default, etc. Haskell is clearly showing its age.
2. Lazy evaluation. Not only does it complicate inspecting what's going on, but also it leads to memory bloat. Don't say you can manage it easily. I had tried that.
3. No stack trace. No, enabling profiling won't help, because thanks to lazy evaluation the exact location of the error will not be given to you.
So, to me, Rust feels like a "saner Haskell". Having a trait system similar to Haskell's type class, but without many of its warts.
That said, if there's a mainstream language that is more similar to Haskell but uses strict evaluation, I will definitely be sold. Idris is one of the contenders, but it isn't quite mainstream yet.
That said, I have a few concerns before actually being sold to F#.
1. F# must interact with the remaining of the .NET ecosystem. So, I think F# may have some interoperability features to ease the process. Wouldn't that increase the complexity of the language? This is a similar concern when I evaluate Scala as an alternative to Haskell. The feature set of Scala looks a bit messy to me, nearly on a par with C++. It could be OK if I use only the "functional" subset of the language. But does it really make me free from e.g. null pointer dereferences?
2. Do F# guys actually develop their "native" libraries not relying on the .NET ones? This is similar to #1 but slightly different. I think if the two languages are somewhat similar, and even share the ecosystem, there may arise a tendency to make libraries that work on both languages. But if one makes a C#-focused library it must not be very easy to use in F#. Is this not a concern in the F# community?
What I find more confusing is C#'s love of mutation. For instance, "fluent" interfaces, where you call an object's method and it returns the same object. I find it confusing in C#, and it seems even more out of place in F#.
F# feels less complex than C# - less "axioms". I've not evaluated this even remotely formally, but it's the feeling I have, being familiar with both. F# really is faster and easier to work with. While yes, F# can't eliminate null references (even inside the language, you can force null) it is far less of an issue.
F# has some of its own libraries, and then also you'll find wrapper libraries to F#-ise other libs. The F# community seems very helpful and excellent. Even the F# team is far more engaged than C#'s ever was. I'm so impressed that once I emailed them with an issue, and Don Syme offered to get me a custom build to tide me over until my problem was officially fixed. This was well after F# has started gaining stream. They are very nice people, and amazingly competent.
I still use half a dozen other languages on a regular basis, so the dream of being able to really focus on just one is still just a dream. However, rust is getting closer, and I'm gradually migrating most of my work to it when the choice is up to me.
It might be better than some of those languages for other reasons though. For instance I think Rust is more expressive than Go. I think it's easier to learn and more practical than Haskell (though I do enjoy me some Haskell too) and I think it has better tooling than all of those mentioned (except Nim, I don't know enough about Nim to pass judgement).
Yes, anything that has a real-time requirement.
Is there ever really a situation where you need to write a web service but cannot afford garbage collection?
Rust is a really cool and novel language. I considered learning it, but since I mostly program web apps and services, I decided to go with Haskell instead. it has much better performance than dynamic languages, but is still garbage collected, because managing memory manually in my code seems like a wasted effort.
I chose Haskell rather than Go just because I like functional idioms, but you could just as easily replace Haskell with Go in the above paragraph.
I mean, I guess the fact that you can write a web app in Rust is cool, I just don't understand why you'd really want to, when there are languages like Haskell and Go (and Nim and D...) that give you fast binaries and garbage collection.