The Nest seems like overkill to me, but let's not pretend that old-fashioned smoke detectors are some kind of awesomely perfected tech.
Learning to cook, ceiling height regulations and hallucinating aren't problems a smoke detector is trying to solve.
Also, if it beeps when there is smoke (from your cooking), it is doing it's intended job.
Fires from cooking (2013) take up nearly 50%!! of residential building fires.
The whole point of the Protect was to get a speaker, microphone and some sensors in every room in a house. It's an obvious requirement for any company with ambitions of winning the connected home. Tweaking lights and thermostat settings from your phone is clearly a stopgap solution. The endgame here is Star Trek style interaction: "Computer - turn the AC down a few degrees."
It was a brilliant ploy and would have worked perfectly except they flubbed the core functionality with various bugs. Normally, that's not a big deal with consumer electronics, but the market is very unforgiving when safety products fail.
It's not really for residential use, but there are definitely use cases for remote smoke detectors.
I have a $20 hunk of plastic on my ceiling. It beeps when it detects smoke, stops when I press the button, and requires battery changes once or twice a year. It doesn't have a smart phone app, wake me up in the middle of the night unnecessarily , cost $100, or add a ridiculous amount of complexity.