News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: More types of flagging? by derefr on Sunday December 20, 2009 @06:27PM (#1006773)
The first thing to determine: are there "nasty users", or simply nasty posts, which could be posted by otherwise-kind people?

Treating nasty users is a simple and well-known problem: find out the user's disposition before you release their commenting privilege. Usually you'd put all the user's writings into a moderation queue, and only post them up (and retroactively make those moderated posts appear) if their average moderation score exceeded some threshold. The moderation could be done by users, of course; in fact, it could simply be part of the normal comment-thread interface, with an icon beside the post to represent that voting on it affects whether the user (and their posts) stay or go.

Treating nasty posts by good users might be similar to a problem of catching illicit activity on a bank account—simply asking the user "Did you really mean to post this? It doesn't seem like something you'd say." It might also be similar to a social bookmarking matchmaking service—except that instead of putting people with high pairwise right-handed Whuffie together, you'd be keeping people with low pairwise left-handed Whuffie apart, by somehow making it harder for them to confront one another.

Re:Ask HN: More types of flagging? by russell on Sunday December 20, 2009 @08:07PM (#1006901)
I think a "Did you mean this?" flag would be useful. Sometimes I find I make a post that could use a little rewording that would make it clearer or less confrontational. I am prone to calling OP's crap (not comments). Perhaps I should apply the moose turd pie principle: Crap...but tasty.
Re:Ask HN: More types of flagging? by jamesbritt on Sunday December 20, 2009 @09:24PM (#1007011)
Good thought. I bet many of the more nasty-prone posters are less likely to revisit their posts to see how they were received, and to consider editing or adding to their posts if flagged as too snarky (or whatever).

Having a way to offer some means of adjustment would help distinguish between the accidental and willful nastiness.

Re:Ask HN: More types of flagging? by HOT_SEX on Tuesday December 29, 2009 @03:32AM (#1020228)
YES