Re:As You Sow Files Notice Of Legal Action Against Soylent S...
by Natsu on Saturday August 15, 2015 @03:59PM
(#10066620)
Sometimes there's an 'unclean hands' defense if someone didn't take reasonable steps to minimize the harm they suffered. Courts can be suspicious of plaintiffs who allow harm to accrue in order to sue for more damages.
That said, I'm only speaking in general. I don't claim to know anything about the factual background of this particular case.
Re:As You Sow Files Notice Of Legal Action Against Soylent S...
by fencepost on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @05:46PM
(#10082441)
And I'll note just for future reference this Ars article: http://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2015/08/watchdog-group-says-s...
As a quick summary, the levels they violate are calculated by finding the level at which there's reproductive toxicity in rats, then dividing by 10. Then dividing again by 1000.
And, the same group "As You Sow" also has a variety of outstanding complaints against chocolate makers for the same thing. The companies there? Ghirardelli, Godiva, Hershey, Lindt & Sprungli, Mondelez, and Earth Cicrle Organics.
Re:As You Sow Files Notice Of Legal Action Against Soylent S...
by DanBC on Sunday August 16, 2015 @03:14AM
(#10068232)
>
So I'm going to paraphrase as follows: "As You Sow," a group claiming to be an environmental watchdog, noted a likely safety problem with Soylent and instead of notifying the manufacturer to minimize the harm to consumers chose to file a lawsuit.
If it was a safety issue they'd have contacted FDA.
It's a regulatory compliance issue.
So I'm going to paraphrase as follows: "As You Sow," a group claiming to be an environmental watchdog, noted a likely safety problem with Soylent and instead of notifying the manufacturer to minimize the harm to consumers chose to file a lawsuit.
Edit: less inflammatory paraphrase