News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: More types of flagging? by pg on Sunday December 20, 2009 @04:55PM (#1006644)
I should probably add a way to flag a story specifically as a dupe, and maybe also for having had the title reworded too egregiously. Those are common problems people currently have to use comments for now. Can anyone think of others?
Re:Ask HN: More types of flagging? by thorax on Sunday December 20, 2009 @05:03PM (#1006660)
I pretty much only flag posts for:

dupe terrible-title spam-site not-even-arguably-hacker-related

Re:Ask HN: More types of flagging? by rms on Sunday December 20, 2009 @09:53PM (#1007041)
Flag as meta? A lot of people don't care for the meta-discussion.
Re:Ask HN: More types of flagging? by decklin on Sunday December 20, 2009 @10:13PM (#1007077)
I would really like to see this. I'm inclined say it shouldn't have any relation to karma or killing, because there's nothing inherently wrong with meta-discussion, but the front page would be infinitely more pleasant to me if I could see "100 comments (90 meta)", instead of guessing if there were really 100 things to say about the article or if after the only 10 someone just hit a nerve with a downvote or a pointless "this isn't HN" snark and started something big and ugly.

I'd go so far as including a "meta" checkbox next to the reply button, defaulting to the parent's value, which it would be considered polite to set truthfully, but maybe that's just me.

Re:Ask HN: More types of flagging? by brk on Sunday December 20, 2009 @05:30PM (#1006699)
Along the same lines, I'd like to see a throttle that limits how many stories a user can submit from the same domain.

There are a handful of users that seem to only submit from 1 or 2 sites that (I presume) they are affiliated with. This is just more noise that makes skimming the /new page and promoting good stories less efficient than it could be.

Regarding titles... What about a title/subtitle option? Keep whatever title the actual article has, and a slightly smaller subtitle where the submitter can editorialize.

Re:Ask HN: More types of flagging? by dhimes on Sunday December 20, 2009 @07:05PM (#1006829)
I dunno. I tend to submit from the same domains simply because there aren't very many submitting from those domains, and the can have interesting articles. On the other hand, I don't submit very often, so maybe some sort of statistical time check would work.
Re:Ask HN: More types of flagging? by brk on Sunday December 20, 2009 @07:17PM (#1006845)
Looking at your submissions, there seems to be enough time between submissions and variety that I don't think you'd get "caught" by what I am proposing.
Re:Ask HN: More types of flagging? by dhimes on Sunday December 20, 2009 @09:42PM (#1007030)
I wasn't just thinking of me.
Re:Ask HN: More types of flagging? by russell on Sunday December 20, 2009 @08:18PM (#1006925)
I flag occasionally for spam or off-topic HN-wise. I have been tempted for those that hijack other stories without much of anything in the way of commentary, but HN'ers tend to quickly post a link to the original.