News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Simple Fix for Drunken Driving: Modest, Immediate Penal... by DanBC on Saturday August 15, 2015 @01:11PM (#10065977)
> > When the state of mind is the same, why should luck in the outcome change the punishment?

> If you don't see the difference between an accident and doing something on purpose as requiring different punishment, well then you just fundamentally disagree with about all of mankind. If your car tire blows and you hit another car and kill someone through no fault of your own, apparently you think that's an equal crime to murder. Really... c'mon... really?

You miss the question here.

If I am driving my car and I take y attetion off the road for a moment to adjust my car radio, and then plough into another car...

1) ... And kill the driver of that other car

2) ... And injure, but don't kill the other driver

Why should y punishment for (1) be more severe than for (2)? My intent was the same, my poor behaviour was the same. Perhaps the difference between causing death and not causing death is the quality of the crashed driver's car.

Murder requires intent to kill. Man-slaughter also requires intent to cause harm. That's why there are seperate laws for vehicular death - causing death by dangerous driving or vehicular manslaughter. It's hard to meet the burden of proof required by murder or manslaughter.

Re:A Simple Fix for Drunken Driving: Modest, Immediate Penal... by sandworm101 on Saturday August 15, 2015 @02:22PM (#10066268)
At some level punishments based on outcome are a practical necessity. We cannot lock up everyone who takes their eyes off the road and causes a minor accident. Even though we know the did everything necessary to cause catastrophic injury, we let them off.

It's a balance between the modern concept of punishments based on state of mind and actions, and the oldschool concept of an eye for an eye, punishment based on outcome.

Re:A Simple Fix for Drunken Driving: Modest, Immediate Penal... by DanBC on Saturday August 15, 2015 @02:31PM (#10066311)
I agree! We create offences of "causing death by dangerous driving" and similar because we need to provide justice for the killed and because murder / manslaughter have (rightly) high burden on proof.