Re:Bayesian Financial Models
by vegabook on Saturday August 15, 2015 @12:54PM
(#10065913)
That is useless in the real world. Trade loses is inevitably a larger absolute value P&L than trade wins. Trade wins frequency > trade loses frequency. Trade loses size > trade wins size. You need both and the analysis only does the former.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Bayes is about working with incomplete information, you don't need all the data, you just need a slight edge. Just because it's not a complete analysis of all necessary input doesn't make it useless. Beyond that, you can directly control your win and loss size with targets and stops, so they're not necessarily unknown, and you certainly know your win/loss ratio which of course you'd want to plug in, at least for money management reasons, especially if you're using any variant of the Kelly formula for position size.
Trade win:lose ratio > 1 is an elementary mistake in algorithmic backtesting. Not knocking Bayes. Only saying the analysis is incomplete. Cancer/noCancer is not a good analogy.
> Trade win:loss ratio > 1 is an elementary mistake in algorithmic backtesting
Who said anything about that? Perhaps I was unclear, it's not about the ratio, it's about the streaks, you need to understand patterns of your wins and losses as it's critical to applying money management. If you only win 30% of the time, you could still make a killing if you can withstand the losing streaks without much drawdown or if the winners are big enough.
Obviously I agree. My simple point is that the OP is making claims about a binary outcome, which could lead one to infer that stock trading binary up/down outcomes are all that matter.