News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Guess which government programs work by michaelt on Friday August 14, 2015 @06:25AM (#10059405)
For certain types of legislation the A/B test itself would create a perverse incentive for opponents of the legislation to make the negative effects occur to get the legislation revoked.

For example, if you said "we're going to put twice as many cops on patrol, but we'll revoke this if crime rates don't decrease" then a rational criminal would commit more crime, in order to get the law revoked.

Or if you said "we're going to tax carbon emissions, but we'll revoke the law if domestic oil production drops by more than 20%" you've just invited oil companies to shut down their wells and wait you out.

Re:Show HN: Guess which government programs work by JamesBarney on Friday August 14, 2015 @11:38AM (#10060707)
It is not in the criminals best interest to commit more crime. One criminal is probably only responsible for .0001% of the crime rate in any given city. So the incentive to commit more crime to revoke the law is infinitesimal. The disincentive created by the increased risk of incarceration would completely overwhelm the incentive to create more crime.

This isn't true when the effects are measured in an industry with only several major actors. For example you decide to test out net neutrality to see what effects it has on broadband cost. So you create a bill that says "Net Neutrality unless broadband costs go up". Then Comcast could just increase their prices to deactivate the bill. But situations like these would be easy to stop and the exception.