Re:Can America cope with a resurgence of tropical disease?
by acdha on Thursday August 13, 2015 @11:07PM
(#10058433)
DDT is still allowed for anti-malaria campaigns but those old approaches aren't used because they don't work: resistance was already recognized as making that approach untenable by the mid-1950s. Even major proponents recognized that they had only a short window for widespread usage before it became ineffective:
“There is an urgency today about malaria eradication. Insects are revealing a disconcerting ability to develop resistance to the new insecticides. For example, houseflies in many areas can no longer be killed with DDT. In a few cases, malaria-type mosquitoes are also resistant. Apparently, it takes six or seven years for the malaria-type mosquitoes of an area under continuous spraying to develop resistance.”
WHO's current position allows DDT for disease control – but not agriculture – but it's also with the kind of controls you'd expect to minimize collateral damage and avoid breeding resistant mosquito populations:
“WHO recommends DDT only for indoor residual spraying. Countries can use DDT for as long as necessary, in the quantity needed, provided that the guidelines and recommendations of WHO and the Stockholm Convention are all met, and until locally appropriate and cost-effective alternatives are available for a sustainable transition from DDT”
Interestingly enough, the DDT boosterism of recent years was apparently funded by tobacco companies trying to discredit the public health agencies which are also behind anti-smoking campaigns. A few researchers connected the dots between that campaign and right-wing cash-for-sciency-veneer activists like Steve Milloy and Roger Bate:
http://link.springer.com/article/10.1007%2FBF02749227?LI=tru...
“There is an urgency today about malaria eradication. Insects are revealing a disconcerting ability to develop resistance to the new insecticides. For example, houseflies in many areas can no longer be killed with DDT. In a few cases, malaria-type mosquitoes are also resistant. Apparently, it takes six or seven years for the malaria-type mosquitoes of an area under continuous spraying to develop resistance.”
WHO's current position allows DDT for disease control – but not agriculture – but it's also with the kind of controls you'd expect to minimize collateral damage and avoid breeding resistant mosquito populations:
“WHO recommends DDT only for indoor residual spraying. Countries can use DDT for as long as necessary, in the quantity needed, provided that the guidelines and recommendations of WHO and the Stockholm Convention are all met, and until locally appropriate and cost-effective alternatives are available for a sustainable transition from DDT”
http://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/10665/69945/1/WHO_HTM_GMP...
(Ars had a great Ed Yong piece last year on the history of resistance through the present: http://arstechnica.com/science/2014/03/a-field-report-from-m...)
Interestingly enough, the DDT boosterism of recent years was apparently funded by tobacco companies trying to discredit the public health agencies which are also behind anti-smoking campaigns. A few researchers connected the dots between that campaign and right-wing cash-for-sciency-veneer activists like Steve Milloy and Roger Bate:
http://www.prospectmagazine.co.uk/magazine/rehabilitatingcar...