News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Samsung unveils 2.5-inch 16TB SSD by jtchang on Thursday August 13, 2015 @01:03PM (#10055622)
Holy that is a lot of storage in a very small amount of space. Besides the fact that I want one right now I am starting to wonder how much heat this will generate.

A lot of 1 unit rack servers can fit about 8 2.5" drives. 128TB of storage in 1U is pretty crazy storage density.

Everytime they reveal a larger capacity drive I just wonder what the backup strategy is going to be. Longer tapes?

Re:Samsung unveils 2.5-inch 16TB SSD by pyre on Thursday August 13, 2015 @01:26PM (#10055799)
Redundant sets of drives... or high density backup tapes. Tape backups have come along with drive size increases:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linear_Tape-Open#Generations

looks like LTO-10 is planned to be 48TB per cartridge.

Re:Samsung unveils 2.5-inch 16TB SSD by dragontamer on Thursday August 13, 2015 @02:16PM (#10056155)
LTO6 is current. LTO7 is "future". LTO8 may never happen, let alone LTO9 or LTO10 (If SSDs prove to be superior to tapes... investments will change for sure.)

The chief benefit of LTO is that it still remains the cheapest and does in fact have huge sequential read/write speeds. Random read/write is even worse than discs but for backup purposes, sequential is king.

Re:Samsung unveils 2.5-inch 16TB SSD by pixl97 on Thursday August 13, 2015 @02:53PM (#10056386)
SSDs may have issues with long term 'disuse', as in you unplug the drive and leave it on the shelf, data loss may occur. With most tapes you can put them in cold storage and they should last decades.
Re:Samsung unveils 2.5-inch 16TB SSD by acdha on Thursday August 13, 2015 @04:11PM (#10056895)
> With most tapes you can put them in cold storage and they should last decades.

This is _hopefully_ true but operational history is so full of unpleasant surprises that I would hesitate to trust any type of storage which isn't regularly verified.

With previous generations of LTO, a colleague had encountered fun failure modes like the media degrading rapidly (unrecoverable in less than a year) when a tape was stored on its side, which turned out to be an “everyone knows” fact not mentioned anywhere in the tape or drive documentation. A difference coworker had encountered some issues with a batch which had a defective lubricant causing the surface to break down over a couple years.

One place we worked with had to carefully de-tune a new tape drive after learning that the old one had drifted out of alignment for at least a year before physically failing, which meant that most of their tapes were no longer readable by a drive in standard calibration.

This is not to say that tape doesn't have a place - analogous failures happen for everything else and the cost-per-GB is appealing. I just don't think we actually have a toss-in-on-the-shelf storage media which can be assumed to work over a long term. You can address those issues with a regimented approach for rotation and mixing physical devices, media, and location but that increases the cost of adding a new storage technology into the mix since you need to develop that operational confidence for each class.

Re:Samsung unveils 2.5-inch 16TB SSD by StillBored on Friday August 14, 2015 @04:10PM (#10062600)
"One place we worked with had to carefully de-tune a new tape drive after learning that the old one had drifted out of alignment for at least a year before physically failing, "

This sounds like a story two decades old, LTO and all modern tape drives have servo tracks on the tapes.. AKA the drive realigns itself to the tape track on the fly as the media passes the head. If the drive cannot do this, you get track following check conditions during the write.

Re:Samsung unveils 2.5-inch 16TB SSD by acdha on Friday August 14, 2015 @04:56PM (#10062876)
That's certainly possible – I thought that was their first generation LTO system but it might have been the previous one which was being replaced. It was a decade ago so both would still have been in service at that time.

The main point in mentioning it wasn't to say that tape is terrible but just that each unique class of hardware brings unique challenges which might not be obvious at first until you have a fair amount of operational time. (Thinking about the people who learned the hard way why RAID arrays should mix hard drives across batches and manufacturers)

Re:Samsung unveils 2.5-inch 16TB SSD by njharman on Friday August 14, 2015 @01:03AM (#10058714)
Yeah but with drives and machines so cheap, most users can keep all their data live, on active drives. Actually on 3 or more drives geographically dispersed.
Re:Samsung unveils 2.5-inch 16TB SSD by merb on Friday August 14, 2015 @10:03AM (#10060130)
We asked Dell for Backup Solutions a while ago, the only thing they told us was that more and more the LTO way of backing up date will decrease and people will focus on offsite cold disk coldstorage. However they forgot that there are customers which don't have many datacenters all over the place...
Re:Samsung unveils 2.5-inch 16TB SSD by gdickie on Thursday August 13, 2015 @01:56PM (#10056008)
For flash devices, power consumption / thermal dissipation is usually a small constant for the control logic, plus a very small amount per read, plus a small amount per (page) write.

If you are limited to the write rate allowed by the SSD interface, then that will serve to limit the heat dissipation as well.

Re:Samsung unveils 2.5-inch 16TB SSD by greedo on Thursday August 13, 2015 @02:05PM (#10056080)
Backup to disk; replicate to an offsite disk array for DR purposes.

EDIT: I should have specified `backup to an SSD storage array.` Disk is just embedded in my brain.

Re:Samsung unveils 2.5-inch 16TB SSD by vegabook on Thursday August 13, 2015 @02:50PM (#10056368)
Tape?? You can get 6TB spinning HD for 300 bucks. Call it 12 grand for 1:1 redundancy on spinning disks @128TB. Spinning disk sequential throughput is more than big enough to do this overnight every day, and probably enough to backup almost live.
Re:Samsung unveils 2.5-inch 16TB SSD by Karunamon on Thursday August 13, 2015 @08:12PM (#10057945)
Brand new LTO4 tapes can be had for about $30, and those go up to 1.6tb compressed, and LTO4 is old tech at this point.
Re:Samsung unveils 2.5-inch 16TB SSD by letstryagain on Friday August 14, 2015 @12:45AM (#10058662)
So... 10 tapes per SSD if your data compresses well. I don't see that as practical at all.
Re:Samsung unveils 2.5-inch 16TB SSD by Karunamon on Friday August 14, 2015 @10:25AM (#10060244)
You mean the tens of thousands of $$$ SSD in the topic?

This can be had right here, right now. Upgrade it to modern tech (LTO6), and you get ~2.5TB/tape for about $60/tape. That's still the absolute best capacity-to-cost ratio for bulk storage that you'll get in 2015.

LTO7 is just around the corner and that tops out at 6.5TB/tape.

Re:Samsung unveils 2.5-inch 16TB SSD by vegabook on Saturday August 15, 2015 @08:40AM (#10065226)
Nobody is arguing that tape doesn't provide the best capacity per dollar. However I get the sense that tape hasn't kept up with spinning disks, let alone SDDs (on Moore's law).

It's just not the 50x factor it once was. More like 10x. Tape is on nobody's radar anymore, whereas as recently as 15 years ago it was still discussed by the mainstream IT commentariat. Gees I even remember PC Magazine recommending desktop users buy some DAT-based tape system. Now, tape is nowhere to be seen.

And that's not really surprising to me when you think that a petabyte of highly responsive spinning disk array can be done for less than a 150 grand, hotswap redundancy included. That's for a superfast 2-d medium as opposed to an eternity-seek-time 1-d medium. Spinning disk is a medium which can be used for live redundancy, a crucial requirement in the internet age.

Sure I think the NSA and GOOG might have need to archive exabytes onto tape. But that's not a mainstream market and for precisely 100% of hacker news readers, tape doesn't exist anymore.

Re:Samsung unveils 2.5-inch 16TB SSD by Karunamon on Sunday August 16, 2015 @01:51PM (#10069641)
Considering that I just picked up a 24 unit LTO5 stacker and a box of tapes for ~750, you may wish to decrement that 100% by a few points :)

The problem with live redundancy is just that, it's live. If your backups are live and online, they are not backups. (For the same reason that RAID is not backup, it's redundancy).

Think less "deployed broken code to prod" and more "this special snowflake server crashed" or "the datacenter caught on fire".

Disaster recovery.

The use case for tape is the same as the use case for something like Amazon Glacier. Perhaps you don't want multiple terabytes of your personal data being sent over the wire to a company who's no doubt been infiltrated by TLA's. Perhaps you want total control of your own data. Perhaps you don't want nasty surprises when it comes to Glacier's retrieval/data in/data out/you-didnt-wait-long-enough fees.

A single LTO5 drive can be had for about $300, tapes for $40/$50, and that'll get you around 2TB of storage each, more if your data compresses well.

Let's not pretend that there aren't real benefits to be had, here. Your use case isn't everyone else's use case, and certainly not enough to be making broad sweeping statements that nobody on HN uses it.