Re:Unbounded High Dynamic Range Photography Using a Modulo C...
by Tloewald on Thursday August 13, 2015 @11:57AM
(#10055141)
All good points. (And my figure actually assumes 10x faster and no loss of time between clearing wells and capturing photons -- i.e. 90% of time is spent capturing photons and 10% is spent clearing the well with no downtime -- to be generous. And, again, just to equal current performance.)
The underlying idea is sound -- storing bits is a linear problem but storing photons is an exponential problem. Of course you're still going to have to dump exponential amounts of energy... (So forget the "unbounded" part.)
Re:Unbounded High Dynamic Range Photography Using a Modulo C...
by paulmd on Thursday August 13, 2015 @12:10PM
(#10055231)
Yeah I was thinking that too. No matter how tiny a capacitor, you have (tens of) millions of them on the sensor, one per photoreceptor, and you're charging and discharging them 100k-10M times per second. That's a lot of energy being accumulated and dissipated right next to the photoreceptors. Thermal noise is gonna be nuts on a modulus sensor, too.
No system is ever unbounded, period, unless you live in a world of frictionless spherical cows. At some point you run into issues caused by accuracy, energy, capacity, etc.
Seems like a better approach would be to add a "gain pixel" to traditional sensors.
So imagine you've got your Bayer grid (or a layout that functions similarly), one of the pixels in the grid gets read out first. That one sets the gain for the ADC for the surrounding pixels. The downside is your iteration couldn't be linear and the gain control would be a lot more complex, but you could do it with technology that actually exists, and you wouldn't lose half of your vertical resolution by doing it a whole line at a time like Magic Lantern's dual-ISO mode.
You'd have to do fancy processing around high-contrast edges, but what else is new.