News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Review my App - Freeciv.net by yungchin on Saturday December 19, 2009 @07:02PM (#1005427)
Edit: nevermind what I wrote below. I just figured out I didn't understand the controls. Would it be impossible to create "drag and drop" for units?

I tried a single-player game in Firefox (3.5), but it hardly reacts to my input (even though top tells me it's barely consuming any cycles). I thought I'd give it a try with the Chromium Beta (but couldn't login anymore, so I created a second account) too - same thing there though.

In any case: love the idea!!!

Re:Ask HN: Review my App - Freeciv.net by nuba on Saturday December 19, 2009 @07:16PM (#1005456)
Cool! Works for me on a firefox 3.6b4, but I found the interface a bit clumsy and lacking visual feedback, and also some may not notice the commands area in the lower-right corner. Otherwise, thanks!
Re:Ask HN: Review my App - Freeciv.net by ugh on Saturday December 19, 2009 @07:12PM (#1005446)
It might not actually be unresponsive but it certainly feels that way. There is no feedback, the screen just violently blacks out, units just jump from A to B, buttons don’t react to clicks at all and so on and so on. This games needs a ton of polish. If anyone ever again claims that animations are useless eye candy I will show them this game.

I love turn based games – but, sorry, not this one. I gave up after a short time and was very frustrated.

(By the way, I changed browsers, too. From Safari to Chrome to Firefox, just to see whether it might be the browser.)

Re:Ask HN: Review my App - Freeciv.net by roschdal on Saturday December 19, 2009 @07:16PM (#1005455)
Thanks for the feedback. How should the controls be for this to be more usable? The game is still under development, so any feedback would be very useful.