News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The story behind ITA's $700M sale to Google (2014) by dmbaggett on Thursday August 13, 2015 @09:49AM (#10054106)
FYI, the transcript kind of mangles what I actually said, so if you have questions, I'm happy to try to answer them.
Re:The story behind ITA's $700M sale to Google (2014) by russnewcomer on Thursday August 13, 2015 @12:17PM (#10055281)
Not exactly related to the interview, but I remember reading about you from some of Andy Gavin's series on Crash, and wondering what the transition from Naughty Dog to ITA was like? I just imagine that personally, I would struggle to transition from game programming where even with great engineering standards, lots of things are more 'get it done fast and close enough to right, and if something just won't work, kluge it together because we have to ship in a week and if there is a collision detection problem leading to a crash because a player jumped from this particular pixel at this particular speed, just put a crate right there so they never can jump from there' and you're doing a AAA title with less than 10 people in less than a year (or whatever the short time horizon was on Crash) to something like ITA where I would imagine there is a lot more rigor and having a tax rule incorrectly applied could be the cause of hundreds of thousands of dollars of loss for you or a client, not to mention it takes five years to build a product.

My question would be, are there any good resources you can point to that would help someone trying to understand what the truly important engineering practices a software developer needs to follow are?

Re:The story behind ITA's $700M sale to Google (2014) by dmbaggett on Thursday August 13, 2015 @12:32PM (#10055390)
You're right that it was a bit different between the two projects. Part of the reason for that, though, is that the tools themselves evolved a lot between the beginning of Crash and the middle/end of ITA. And ITA was a linux SaaS shop, so we benefited from all the improvements to tools in that stack.

With respect to resources on practices, I think most of the agile literature is reasonable. In all the domains I've worked in, the biggest challenge with doing things agile-ly has been testing: the domain complexity makes it very hard to comprehensively test the software. In the case of Crash, we just dealt with it with huge amounts of human testing (and we fixed the hundreds of reported buts). At ITA and Inky, we had/have more custom automated testing infrastructure.

One lesson is that a system like ITA's or Inky's basically can't be correct unless it's exhaustively tested.

Re:The story behind ITA's $700M sale to Google (2014) by edwinnathaniel on Thursday August 13, 2015 @12:50PM (#10055514)
Hear Hear.

My previous employer is in the field of network and application performance management. Even with unit-test, integration-test, and some functional-test, we can't be 100% sure we've covered everything (e.g.: different network setup) due to the domain complexity.

Having said that, "testing" has always been the biggest issue for any shop that call themselves "Agile" and it's also my screening test when interviewing with any company that claim themselves "agile": "let's talk about automation test..." :)

Re:The story behind ITA's $700M sale to Google (2014) by aidenn0 on Thursday August 13, 2015 @01:34PM (#10055864)
Testing (particularly integration testing) is just as important in non-agile shops. The difference between companies that do a lot of regular testing (whether automated or just with a big testing department) is huge.
Re:The story behind ITA's $700M sale to Google (2014) by chipilov on Thursday August 13, 2015 @10:35AM (#10054501)
Hi David, I was wondering if you could elaborate a little more on this thought:

"...for us to really take it to the next level and long-term defend ourselves against competition from the Sabre-s of the world, we would need to build our own reservation system and start hosting airlines. We would have to NOT be just a search provider, we would have to provide the whole platform for a major airline."

Is the sole reason for this the fact that the Sabre-s can always undercut you by providing the search for free or is there more to it? Do you know if Google will try to follow (or if they already have) that approach? Is it possible that the emergence of so many new online travel sites has changed the scope of opportunity for pure search providers?

Thanks!

Re:The story behind ITA's $700M sale to Google (2014) by dmbaggett on Thursday August 13, 2015 @11:18AM (#10054834)
No, that's pretty much it. I recall a specific interaction I had with a South American carrier that really colored my opinion of the future of our company. We were pitching them on our search system and it was going well for a while. But then they told us that their hosting provider had offered to lower their distribution fees through travel agents by some material percentage if they used their search instead of ours... and their CFO essentially made them take the deal.

I seriously doubt the proliferation of travel sites has changed the leverage of the parties much: you can still count on one hand the number of entities that offer all of search, distribution, and hosting. They will remain an oligopoly for some time to come, and will, I'm sure, continue to use that to their advantage.

Regarding Google (or Alphabet, or whatever they are now), I have no idea. I didn't stay on after the merger, and frankly don't ever talk to them because every conversation I've ever had with them has been totally one-sided. (They expect me to tell them stuff, and then won't say anything... because Google secrets matter!)

Re:The story behind ITA's $700M sale to Google (2014) by corford on Thursday August 13, 2015 @12:37PM (#10055424)
This is why I really hope NDC (http://www.iata.org/whatwedo/airline-distribution/ndc/pages/...) takes off, airlines simplify their fare rules, invest in IT talent and start self hosting.

Travel providers could then connect directly to an airline's NDC API for scheduling, pricing and ticketing without the need for middlemen and gatekeepers.

Distribution would finally be back under the airline's control and there would be a lot more innovation.

Re:The story behind ITA's $700M sale to Google (2014) by skewart on Thursday August 13, 2015 @05:02PM (#10057195)
NDC sounds awesome, and so do simplified fare rules. Are there any seriously misaligned incentives that would prevent it from happening, or is it more just general bureaucratic slowness?
Re:The story behind ITA's $700M sale to Google (2014) by corford on Thursday August 13, 2015 @06:11PM (#10057538)
The NDC spec is still evolving (and suffering from a bit of mission creep). There's also the chicken and egg problem - airlines aren't going to invest in building in-house NDC based hosting and distribution platforms until there's enough market demand for it. Market demand wont appear until airlines start distributing over NDC.

I'd have thought too that the GDS providers aren't exactly thrilled by the prospect of being easily cut out of the distribution chain... There will still be a need for aggregators though since not all travel providers will have the technical know-how or desire to develop their own NDC capable platforms/software. NDC would just level the playing field a bit.

Re:The story behind ITA's $700M sale to Google (2014) by aiiane on Thursday August 13, 2015 @12:25PM (#10055338)
Google tried it (search for Google ITA PSS).
Re:The story behind ITA's $700M sale to Google (2014) by corford on Thursday August 13, 2015 @12:52PM (#10055529)
Hi David

The interview was fascinating, really enjoyed it!

When you were talking about the complexity of airline fares it reminded me of ATPCO. Did they exist back then or was that something the airlines later brought into being themselves?

Re:The story behind ITA's $700M sale to Google (2014) by dmbaggett on Thursday August 13, 2015 @01:11PM (#10055698)
Yes, they existed, and that's where we got the fare data from.
Re:The story behind ITA's $700M sale to Google (2014) by asavadatti on Thursday August 13, 2015 @02:44PM (#10056323)
How important was the collapse of the Air Canada deal to the Google acquisition? (I worked on the RES/Avail systems in '09)
Re:The story behind ITA's $700M sale to Google (2014) by ScottBurson on Thursday August 13, 2015 @07:38PM (#10057842)
Were you involved in the decision to use Common Lisp?