In our organization, the value-add is forcing everyone to be on the same work schedule, promulgating organizational culture, giving managers an idea of peoples' workload so they can load-balance, and meeting the need of people to socialize. We cross-staff on a per-matter basis, and we'll generally conduct inter-team communication over email and phone whether even when the team is within a few doors of each other. Email is efficient and asynchronous. We get together in person at milestone events, where, e.g., the whole team will fly in and take over a conference room for a day or two to prepare for a big upcoming event.
If you think the value-add of offices is facilitating informal, day-to-day inter-team communication, than obviously having people in different offices makes reorganization harder. And admittedly, its been years since I was on a software team. That said, even at that time, I found people dropping by my cube, instead of emailing, to ask a question about an API I restructured to be annoying rather than productive. It's PIO instead of DMA--a waste of clock cycles.
YMMV.
Right, which I think is a calculation people need to take seriously. There are real benefits and trade-offs on either side and articles arguing that one is uniformly better than the other always come across as terribly misguided to me.
The physical and social environment that a social animal like a human spends the majority of their waking day in has a profound impact on almost every aspect of their lives. We should be thoughtful about how we arrange it.
There also is a definite benefit to letting less-skilled developers interrupt the more skilled. Skilled developers without interruption kind of become data silos. They're extremely productive, but they could have a multiplicative effect on others' productivity that is wasted.
Even if most interruptions are useless, it's still worth it for the times when a senior dev stops a junior dev from wasting a week puzzling over a stack trace or implementing something useless.
To rephrase, think if WeWork closed their doors to non-WeWork employees, and let their employees work from any WeWork, or from home.
Very apparent how bad it was when DuPont of all companies even moved out of the downtown area.
http://www.newsweek.com/2014/12/19/wilmington-delaware-murde...
I've heard that Austin TX is a good city for CS people - high paying jobs, low(ish) cost of living.
I think for large companies this is an excellent alternative and solves the problem where employees can't telecommute because of sensitive IP or security clearance.
I live in Baltimore now, and before that in Wilmington, and I'm astonished that more companies don't have offices in those cities. Both cities have a lot less traffic than D.C. and Philadelphia, respectively, and are well-served by rail. I'd imagine there would be a lot of talented people who would sign up at offices in those cities so long as they weren't backoffice locations and they could still do frontline work.