SO, while you were claiming the above poster was using bad numbers by using "the last 6 years," you are similarly using biased data by looking at the past 15 years because that's the eve of the dot com bust.
Edit: looks like without inflation, if this calculator is to be believed:
http://dqydj.net/sp-500-return-calculator/
The annualized return for the past 15 years with both dividends and inflation is under 2%.
I know that I'm cherry-picking by using a 15 year period. That was my entire point: that you can cherry-pick to find almost any rate of return.
However, that particular period is still pretty relevant. If your plan is to spend 10% of your savings per year, then a 15-year period of zero (or just small) returns will wipe you out. Even if it bounces back afterwards, you're still screwed.
On an inflation-adjusted basis, the S&P 500 has not grown at all for the past 15 years:
http://www.multpl.com/inflation-adjusted-s-p-500
The average rate of return for the past 50 years is pretty small. You can make almost any rate of return look reasonable if you cherry-pick the right timeframe, but the long-term average doesn't look good at all.