Re:GitHub's Atom Switches from the Open Code of Conduct to t...
by djur on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @05:30PM
(#10044549)
ESR has political motivations to oppose these CoCs, and the strongest argument that post makes is an attempt at guilt by association. I found it extremely unconvincing.
Re:GitHub's Atom Switches from the Open Code of Conduct to t...
by josteink on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @05:52PM
(#10044658)
He has his political motivation, just like the CoCers have theirs. This probably applies to everyone, so it's not an argument which can be used to blanket reject a statement as such.
His political position is that open source projects should be about the code, not gender, politics and endless subjects ripe for tactical abuse and causing drama.
Personally I find that a perfectly reasonable and rational position. What fault do you find with it?
Re:GitHub's Atom Switches from the Open Code of Conduct to t...
by GFK_of_xmaspast on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @05:54PM
(#10044669)
ESR is against a lot of things, like 'not being a racist.'
ESR has written about one of the CoC authors here: https://archive.is/6F9Yr
Tldr: the people who claims to deliver a product providing order and civility (the "CoC") are usually the people who are conducting the abusive behaviour.
In such a CoC is very alarming signal with regard to who is in charge of a project's management.