News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Problems with Computer Science Education by lordnacho on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @04:27PM (#10044134)
Looking at my brother, who is about to finish CS at Columbia, I don't recognize the criticism. He seems to have a good mix of theory and practice. There's a fair amount of grinding ("argh why won't it compile? / Google the error") as well as working with other students. There's also a huge amount of data structures and algorithm stuff that you expect in this sort of course. I didn't see a lot of reading other people's code, but maybe that's in there as well somewhere. I definitely get the feeling there's a lot of mini-projects.

Of course there are things that are much easier to learn on the job, such as how to navigate a huge codebase. Because you'll have time to do that. Also architecture decisions are hard to get right as a novice. You can read around, you can ask people questions, but in the end you need to make mistakes and rebuild to appreciate some aspects.

Re:Problems with Computer Science Education by quicksilver on Tuesday August 11, 2015 @09:32PM (#10045520)
I just graduated from CU, and I'd agree. Just based on anecdotal evidence comparing w/ friends from Cal, MIT, Harvard, etc, I think all of these 'top' schools do a pretty good job of mixing theory and practice within the required/core CS classes, and then allow the students to decide for themselves which track they want to follow. For instance at Columbia, we have tracks in AI, Applications, Theory/Security (forget the exact name but this is theory & algorithmic heavy), Systems, etc. These tracks comprise several senior / master / phd level courses which you usually take in your last year or two. No matter which track you go into, all CS majors take the same core CS classes in data structures, basic CS/compiler/language theory, statistics, linear algebra, etc.

I can't say that any of the core classes involve navigating a huge codebase... there are certainly some upper level track classes (especially in Systems) that give you that experience, but I do agree that is relatively uncommon.

Honestly so much of the learning happens in extracurriculars (Hackathons, CS/tech clubs, etc) that it's hard to keep track of which skills you learn in classes vs just doing other activities with friends. I think the power of college resides in the strength of such extracurriculars.