News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Algorithmic Trading: The Play-at-Home Version by joosters on Monday August 10, 2015 @02:35PM (#10036361)
The 'zero-sum game' part is meaningless and adds no insight here. It doesn't matter whether you believe trading/gambling is zero-sum or not.

For instance, imagine you have a poker-playing bot at a poker table, where the house takes no cut of the stakes. Zero-sum? Yes. But your bot has to be better than the other players, and win more than its running costs in order to profit. Now imagine the same situation but the house does take a cut. Zero-sum? Not any more. But your bot still has to be better than the other players and its running costs in order to profit. The house 'rake' just increases your operating costs.

I think you are confusing the issue with large scale HFT (where companies pay more and more for slightly faster comms), which is a world away from the trading strategies the article is talking about.

Re:Algorithmic Trading: The Play-at-Home Version by SonicSoul on Monday August 10, 2015 @02:58PM (#10036515)
Think you missed the point. All he was saying (I believe) that no matter how good your models are it's still a race between the players to get the biggest share of the pot. The more players the less chance you have
Re:Algorithmic Trading: The Play-at-Home Version by joosters on Monday August 10, 2015 @03:21PM (#10036659)
That's true of many endeavors, and is unrelated to any 'zero-sum' argument.
Re:Algorithmic Trading: The Play-at-Home Version by jsprogrammer on Monday August 10, 2015 @03:00PM (#10036525)
Another way to look at your 'profit' is just as an increase in the operating costs of all the other players and the house.

I think the zero-sum part implies that this type of trading is not actually productive. At this point, it is literally just modifying numbers represented as fluctuations in local electro-magnetic fields instead of something useful like carrying spices from one continent to another.

Re:Algorithmic Trading: The Play-at-Home Version by fluidcruft on Monday August 10, 2015 @03:06PM (#10036557)
That's the logic suckers use when buying bitcoin mining hardware.