News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Have you pondered the moral implications of your startup? by edw519 on Friday January 18, 2008 @10:51AM (#100339)
Stop worrying. Now.

Every nanosecond you worry about this is a resource permanently lost from where it belongs: your startup.

What if Henry Ford hesitated because he worried about drunk drivers? Or Edison and Bell hesitated because they worried about drug dealers and criminals? We'd still have automobiles, lights, and phones. But you would have never heard of any of them.

You have little or no control over this. Have a little faith in others; stepping forward to confront evil is their thing. In the meantime, do yours.

Re:Have you pondered the moral implications of your startup? by kogir on Friday January 18, 2008 @12:29PM (#100381)
I think that if there is something you can do to prevent or discourage the use of your creation for evil purposes, then you should do everything in your power to do so.

Sometimes doing so is also critical to keeping your users, especially if they entrust you with something useful but dangerous.

At Loopt I think about things like this a lot, and I hope that doing so has made the service safer and harder to subvert for common questionable or evil purposes.

Simply ignoring the issues would have been negligence.

Re:Have you pondered the moral implications of your startup? by ntoshev on Friday January 18, 2008 @11:55AM (#100368)
Thinking about how to nurture your community is not a waste of time. The right community is vitally important to many startups, certainly not less important than the technology (Reddit and Wikipedia are both good examples).

He has control over the community in the way he implements its mechanisms of interaction. Crash course here:

http://www.joelonsoftware.com/articles/BuildingCommunitieswi...

Re:Have you pondered the moral implications of your startup? by ecommercematt on Friday January 18, 2008 @11:13AM (#100350)
Thanks for your feedback. I agree that protracted hand-wringing over the potential outcomes of my startup would be a waste of time. Nonetheless, I think it is worth pondering the issue.

In a sense, the specific problems I raised with Reddit are just a subset of a larger issue: community-driven sites rotting at their core. Sometimes they rot at their core due to racists (and other types of bigots and hate mongers) spouting off, and sometimes they rot at their core due to idiots being idiots, and sometimes they rot at their core due to spammers.

I raised the topic because I've heard plenty of ideas on how to reduce the number/influence of idiots and spammers on community-driven sites, but I have heard far less about how to prevent hate from taking hold. This is important not just because racism and other forms of bigotry harm society, but because prominently featured prejudice-based hatred diminishes the credibility of the information a given community creates/organizes just as much as idiots and spammers do.

Our concept is not really like Reddit (or Wikipedia), and we think it is less vulnerable to the rot-inducing influences I referenced above.

Re:Have you pondered the moral implications of your startup? by boredguy8 on Friday January 18, 2008 @12:05PM (#100372)
The hottest fires in hell are reserved for those who remain neutral in times of moral crisis.
Re:Have you pondered the moral implications of your startup? by edw519 on Friday January 18, 2008 @01:37PM (#100419)
How is building something people can use (or possibly misuse) the same as remaining neutral?
Re:Have you pondered the moral implications of your startup? by aston on Friday January 18, 2008 @06:44PM (#100613)
It's a moot point anyway because most of the time when you make a moral stand in your product you end up making the experience for its audience better. The tricky part is knowing which types of people you'll lose or gain based on those moral stands.