News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How the United States Lost the Naval War of 2015 by hugh_ on Friday December 18, 2009 @10:42AM (#1003256)
For those who can't be bothered reading it, the posited scenario goes something like this:

1. China torpedoes a US aircraft carrier for no particularly good reason

2. China claims that the US aircraft carrier exploded all on its own, and nobody can prove otherwise

3. The US doesn't bother to retaliate

4. The US has thus "lost the Naval War of 2015".

Does this scenario strike anyone as especially plausible?

Re:How the United States Lost the Naval War of 2015 by stcredzero on Friday December 18, 2009 @11:03AM (#1003308)
There would be records of the radar track in the computers of the Aegis cruisers in the task force. There may well be evidence of the launch captured by satellites.

ELINT is very powerful, and the US intelligence agencies have been at this game since before WWII. Their sneakiness boggles the mind! They were using signals bounced off of the moon to spy on Soviet equipment, and disguised the whole thing as radio astronomy!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hFSPHfZQpIQ

If you are going to go up against the US defense establishment, you'd better be damned sure you know what you're doing.

If I were the US, facing such an asymmetric threat, I'd keep most of my carrier groups around for the short term as a boondoggle, then come up with my own novel threat against my opponent's shipping.

(Sub launched cruise missiles, or mines? The advanced 21st century version, of course.)

Re:How the United States Lost the Naval War of 2015 by hugh_ on Friday December 18, 2009 @11:17AM (#1003340)
(Sub launched cruise missiles, or mines?)

Nukes.

If I were the US, I'd simply make it an official matter of policy that any attack from a nuclear power would result in an immediate nuclear response, the logic being that once two nuclear powers are at war it's probably going to turn nuclear eventually, so you might as well make the first strike.

Re:How the United States Lost the Naval War of 2015 by synnik on Friday December 18, 2009 @11:26AM (#1003365)
Please tell me you are joking.

Some of us spent our entire youth afraid of nuclear annihilation 24/7. We've been out of that for some time now, but I don't think anyone wants to send the world back to that point.

Re:How the United States Lost the Naval War of 2015 by barrkel on Friday December 18, 2009 @01:32PM (#1003628)
Fear of nuclear annihilation is why there hasn't been a war. Nuclear weapons = peace. Not a happy peace, but infinitely better than either no nukes or a single side having nukes.
Re:How the United States Lost the Naval War of 2015 by eru on Friday December 18, 2009 @03:32PM (#1003877)
You know that there were more hot wars during the cold war than we have now?
Re:How the United States Lost the Naval War of 2015 by nfnaaron on Friday December 18, 2009 @12:04PM (#1003438)
If I were the US, I'd simply make it a matter of official policy to make as many official, unofficial, formal, informal, commercial and personal ties to every country in the world as possible, to the maximum extent that any ideology on either side allows.

Yes, certainly we need to maintain defensive and offensive military capabilities, but I think we should be doing much, much more to reduce the need for those capabilities.

Re:How the United States Lost the Naval War of 2015 by dflock on Friday December 18, 2009 @10:36PM (#1004457)
This is, more or less, the original founding intent of the European Union. Given that the last 60 years has been free of major land wars in Europe - the longest period of peace on the continent since the fall of the Roman Empire in ~470AD, it seems to be working fairly well. (ref: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pax_Europaea).
Re:How the United States Lost the Naval War of 2015 by maelstrom on Saturday December 19, 2009 @02:01PM (#1005012)
I think the EU is great, but I wonder how much of that peace can be attributed to both the United States and USSR both having large armies camped through Europe for most of that time.
Re:How the United States Lost the Naval War of 2015 by nfnaaron on Saturday December 19, 2009 @02:17PM (#1005036)
I had the same thought. The answer is there is no one thing that does/did it. I'm sure it doesn't hurt that Germany and France are closer to partners than combatants.
Re:How the United States Lost the Naval War of 2015 by dflock on Sunday December 20, 2009 @05:17AM (#1005988)
Yeah, external factors like those mentioned obviously play a part, as do internal factors, as taught to us by playing Civilisation - fat happy democracies don't like making war very much, or for very long; it's expensive and you have to get off the couch...
Re:How the United States Lost the Naval War of 2015 by run4yourlives on Friday December 18, 2009 @12:04PM (#1003437)
Well, I guess the whole world can thank their deity of choice that you're nowhere near being in charge of anything.
Re:How the United States Lost the Naval War of 2015 by barrkel on Friday December 18, 2009 @01:31PM (#1003625)
The others may mock you, but you are in fact correct as to why it is impossible for two nuclear-armed foes to fight directly.

There will never be a hot war between US and China for so long as nuclear weapons have no effective defense. Nuclear weapons are probably the single biggest enabler of peace on the planet.

Re:How the United States Lost the Naval War of 2015 by run4yourlives on Friday December 18, 2009 @02:36PM (#1003775)
>There will never be a hot war between US and China for so long as nuclear weapons have no effective defense.

I beg to differ. First, see India v. Pakistan as a direct counter to your "impossible" statement.

Second, as the example shows, the line you draw regarding using nukes does not extend all the way down to the rifleman. It's entirely possible to start a conventional and/or localized war with the understanding that you intend to win and therefore do not have the need to use your nukes.

You're making the major mistake though of assuming your enemy is a rational actor, a la the cold war. Russia is a rational actor. So is China. Even India.

In Pakistan however, only a minority are rational actors. Should a change in government occur that is pro-Taliban, you now have a nation of irrational actors with nuclear weapons.

MAD falls apart at this point. The fear of death means little to the Muslim extremist, and a man that isn't scared does highly irrational things, like nuke a civilian target.

All it takes is one, and then all bets are off.

Re:How the United States Lost the Naval War of 2015 by etherael on Monday December 21, 2009 @09:23PM (#1009241)
So, how to fix the religious, then?
Re:How the United States Lost the Naval War of 2015 by cabalamat on Friday December 18, 2009 @12:01PM (#1003429)
> China torpedoes a US aircraft carrier for no particularly good reason

No. The scenario is that China hits a US carrier with a (conventionally armed) ballistic missile, for no particularly good reason

Re:How the United States Lost the Naval War of 2015 by hugh_ on Friday December 18, 2009 @12:13PM (#1003457)
I stand corrected. Don't aircraft carriers have pretty good missile defence systems, though?
Re:How the United States Lost the Naval War of 2015 by HistoryInAction on Friday December 18, 2009 @12:40PM (#1003523)
It's the bullet-hitting-bullet problem. Some labs are working on focusing light on targets to melt key components. Others do a 'metal sheet' in pellet form with the thought that if you put enough metal in the air, you're bound to hit targets...
Re:How the United States Lost the Naval War of 2015 by ptomato on Friday December 18, 2009 @12:31PM (#1003506)
No. They have effectively none.
Re:How the United States Lost the Naval War of 2015 by jfoutz on Friday December 18, 2009 @12:45PM (#1003532)
http://www.globalsecurity.org/military/systems/ship/cvn-68.h...

The NIMITZ-class self-defense measures include: missiles, guns, and electronic warfare. The NATO Sea Sparrow Missile System is comprised of two launchers with eight missiles each. Sea Sparrow is a radar-guided, short-to-medium range missile capable of engaging aircraft and cruise missiles. NIMITZ-class also has Close-In Weapon System mounts for short range defense against aircraft or missiles. Each mount has its own search and track radar, and a six-barrel, 20-millimeter Gatling gun capable of firing 3,000 rounds per minute

Re:How the United States Lost the Naval War of 2015 by ajross on Friday December 18, 2009 @01:06PM (#1003575)
Untrue. The entirety of surface fleet doctrine in the modern USN is focused on protection of the carriers (and other force projection ships) from attack. Pretty much every ship you see is a "carrier defense mechanism", as are most of the aircraft on deck.
Re:How the United States Lost the Naval War of 2015 by cabalamat on Friday December 18, 2009 @03:46PM (#1003900)
They have plenty of defences. However, a ballistica missile re-entering is going very fast and is therefore very hard to intercept. It is also not a threat that carrier battle groups have been designed to combat.
Re:How the United States Lost the Naval War of 2015 by tokenadult on Friday December 18, 2009 @10:45AM (#1003264)
Couldn't the United States send some nuclear-tipped missiles to China in response, and then claim the explosions were simply explosions of the warheads stockpiled in China? I just don't buy 3. as a likely response. Possible, but not likely.
Re:How the United States Lost the Naval War of 2015 by hugh_ on Friday December 18, 2009 @10:51AM (#1003278)
And unless step 3 seems not just "likely" but "damn near certain", there's no way the Chinese are going to be dumb enough to attempt step 1.