Re:You Can Prove a Negative [pdf]
by jsprogrammer on Saturday August 08, 2015 @07:20PM
(#10028940)
I agree you can think about it on that level.
However, there is a level where it is not about the words, but the actual things. In your example, the word 'alien' is real, but there is no 'real' definition of it, in the sense that there is no definition that can be given that could select an actual instance of 'alien' (I may have confused the quotes by this point) precisely (perhaps) because 'aliens' don't actually exist (even though there is a word that can be mapped to some vague concept of what an alien might actually be like).
You are confusing a "real definition" with a "definition of something real".
The concept 'alien' is actually pretty well defined and specific, the least specific part of it is probably the definition of 'life'.
>a) The thing itself b) A name for the thing itself
Yes, that is generally accepted. Generally philosophers talk about the name, 'A', the thing, A.
> It would seem the obvious answer is, no.
If you think that is obvious, you need to spend more time thinking about it. For example, you seem to be implying that we don't know if 'alien' is a real word or not since we don't know if aliens exist. (Some people may claim to know, but most of us have not seen proof.)