The Tangled Web is better for learning the underlying causes of various issues presented in the former book and for learning how to prevent them. It has excellent, practical checklists at the end of every chapter for anyone building an application.
(I write high-security software. )
Burp is the industry standard. It's also a criminally underrated dev tool. If you're getting paid to build web applications, you should own a license.
Similarly, the online stuff is totally optional, and none of the master WAHH crafstmen I know have needed that in the slightest.
It is pretty clear in reading those reviews that a person can, with no investment of time or effort, write bad reviews about anything.
It takes effort and energy to get the most out of WAHH, and you can do it without spending an additional dime.
If you are too cheap to spend $7 an hour, you can set up a vulnerable VM and accomplish the same thing for free.
The Tangled Web is a good primer on browser security, which is a deeper topic.
The OWASP Top 10 is worth knowing because it's a widely recognized metric, but OWASP itself is not an especially great resource.