News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google In Discussions To Acquire Yelp For A Half Billion ... by ShabbyDoo on Thursday December 17, 2009 @10:20PM (#1002482)
Doesn't Yelp offer astro-turfing for $$$? I hope that this practice doesn't fall under the umbrella of "don't be evil."
Re:Google In Discussions To Acquire Yelp For A Half Billion ... by seldo on Thursday December 17, 2009 @10:27PM (#1002491)
The accusation much more frequently levelled is that they extort business to pay to have negative reviews hidden:

http://www.eastbayexpress.com/eastbay/yelp-and-the-business-...

It's not lying -- the good reviews that remain come from real people -- but it's certainly misleading.

Re:Google In Discussions To Acquire Yelp For A Half Billion ... by efsavage on Friday December 18, 2009 @12:01PM (#1003428)
I can vouch that negative reviews can be hidden, my friend wrote one and he sees "23 reviews" including his own, when he is logged in. Everyone else sees "22 reviews" and his is omitted.
Re:Google In Discussions To Acquire Yelp For A Half Billion ... by eli on Friday December 18, 2009 @11:14AM (#1003331)
That article isn't exactly airtight in the evidence department.
Re:Google In Discussions To Acquire Yelp For A Half Billion ... by seldo on Thursday December 17, 2009 @10:25PM (#1002488)
Google's don't-be-evil policy bit the dust as soon as they bought DoubleClick, as far as I'm concerned. Their new policy can be accurately summed up as "be less evil than Microsoft", which has understandably given them a lot of headroom to expand.
Re:Google In Discussions To Acquire Yelp For A Half Billion ... by houseabsolute on Friday December 18, 2009 @12:21AM (#1002589)
Not a fair representation of Google's operations.
Re:Google In Discussions To Acquire Yelp For A Half Billion ... by liquidcool on Friday December 18, 2009 @12:01AM (#1002568)
Don't be evil is very difficult for a publicly held corporation. Their true mission, despite any noble intentions of their founders, is to increase value to the shareholders.

For me the first, "that sounds kinda evil" moment was the compliance with gov't censorship (and possibly private data sharing) in countries with poor human rights records. As someone stated, MS (and Yahoo) do the same, but it's still kind of sad.

Re:Google In Discussions To Acquire Yelp For A Half Billion ... by litewulf on Friday December 18, 2009 @04:47AM (#1002877)
I'm curious, do you think Google should operate in the United States? There are laws that could be used to force Google to say turn over your private data. Would not then the same argument apply?

On the other hand, the value of being able to use Google, despite its marginal risk, seems quite a good "exchange" for many people (that is, the usefulness of say search being weighed off against getting rounded up in say a war on child porn). I think there is a value judgement that is much more nuanced than what you are suggesting.

Re:Google In Discussions To Acquire Yelp For A Half Billion ... by josefresco on Friday December 18, 2009 @09:48AM (#1003169)
See, when our (US) government does it ...it's okay. It's just those other evil countries that are wrong when they demand user data from an Internet company.
Re:Google In Discussions To Acquire Yelp For A Half Billion ... by liquidcool on Saturday December 19, 2009 @03:52AM (#1004607)
Yes, there is certainly a value judgement here. This is why I was careful to use the term "poor human rights record". I'm sure there are many that think the US has a poor human rights record, and I know there is always room for improvement, but I'm certainly not afraid to use my Google account here.

For a more quantifiable ranking of countries, see:

http://www.carleton.ca/cifp/app/gdp_ranking.php

Re:Google In Discussions To Acquire Yelp For A Half Billion ... by InclinedPlane on Friday December 18, 2009 @01:07AM (#1002643)
If everyone lived by the "it's not THAT evil, 'cause everyone else does it" motto the world would be a vastly more horrific place.
Re:Google In Discussions To Acquire Yelp For A Half Billion ... by palish on Friday December 18, 2009 @06:10AM (#1002941)
Thinking about it... Everyone does live by that motto. Mostly.
Re:Google In Discussions To Acquire Yelp For A Half Billion ... by tdoggette on Thursday December 17, 2009 @10:25PM (#1002486)
http://www.theregister.co.uk/2007/01/10/yelp_reviewers_paid/

This seems like they paid people to write reviews, but I see no suggestion that they instructed paid reviewers to be biased. More content is better for everyone, as far as I can tell.

Another Register article (http://www.theregister.co.uk/2009/02/19/yelp_pitch_revisited...) seems to be at most an accusation of unethical ad sales tactics, and it includes the CEO flat-out denying that they'd ever manipulated reviews for money.

Re:Google In Discussions To Acquire Yelp For A Half Billion ... by liquidcool on Friday December 18, 2009 @12:05AM (#1002579)
I really like Yelp and I think it's a great service, but I don't contribute because of the complete lack of data portability. Even their RSS feeds are heavily truncated. I'd contribute significantly if this changed. For instance, automatically posting my Yelp reviews to my blog would be a big incentive.
Re:Google In Discussions To Acquire Yelp For A Half Billion ... by brianobush on Thursday December 17, 2009 @10:03PM (#1002471)
well, they have almost 22B dollars sitting in cash. from an investor's point of view, that is wasteful. Easy way to turn that cash into growing revenue streams is to purchase profitable companies. Though 500 mil is a bit steep to pay for yelp IMHO.
Re:Google In Discussions To Acquire Yelp For A Half Billion ... by sachinag on Thursday December 17, 2009 @10:42PM (#1002500)
Yelp is sitting on a massive store of local business data. That's useful for search quality. Yelp is in the first three results for the majority of businesses in their database. That's useful for search monetization. They also have a direct sales force calling on local SMEs. That's useful for Google Apps. I could go on.
Re:Google In Discussions To Acquire Yelp For A Half Billion ... by nudist on Thursday December 17, 2009 @11:18PM (#1002531)
More valuable than all that is the fact that Yelp is the de-facto real-world review site. Its brand is powerful, about as powerful as YouTube's was when Google bought them.
Re:Google In Discussions To Acquire Yelp For A Half Billion ... by josefresco on Friday December 18, 2009 @09:51AM (#1003173)
I have to disagree. Unless you live in a city, your average person has never heard of Yelp. When Google bought YouTube it was a different story.
Re:Google In Discussions To Acquire Yelp For A Half Billion ... by wmeredith on Friday December 18, 2009 @10:16AM (#1003205)
I concur. I live in kansas City and work on computers all day. I've heard of Yelp, but I've never used them or seen them pop up in search results for local business.
Re:Google In Discussions To Acquire Yelp For A Half Billion ... by ams6110 on Friday December 18, 2009 @10:46AM (#1003268)
Yeah, my first reaction reading this headline was "who/what is Yelp?"
Re:Google In Discussions To Acquire Yelp For A Half Billion ... by pmorici on Thursday December 17, 2009 @11:42PM (#1002552)
Maybe in the bay area. I'd never heard of yelp until I visited the area.
Re:Google In Discussions To Acquire Yelp For A Half Billion ... by warfangle on Friday December 18, 2009 @01:56AM (#1002722)
Also in NYC. Heck, it's even good for restaurant reviews when I visit home in NC.
Re:Google In Discussions To Acquire Yelp For A Half Billion ... by natrius on Thursday December 17, 2009 @11:38PM (#1002547)
A year or two ago, there were plenty of cities where Citysearch was more dominant than Yelp. I suspect this is still the case.
Re:Google In Discussions To Acquire Yelp For A Half Billion ... by sachinag on Friday December 18, 2009 @12:05AM (#1002576)
Apparently, they've been neck and neck for about a year: http://siteanalytics.compete.com/yelp.com+citysearch.com+met...
Re:Google In Discussions To Acquire Yelp For A Half Billion ... by adatta02 on Thursday December 17, 2009 @11:59PM (#1002566)
I'm in Boston and I agree, Yelp is pretty much the de-facto real world review site.
Re:Google In Discussions To Acquire Yelp For A Half Billion ... by steveplace on Friday December 18, 2009 @10:41AM (#1003254)
from an investor's point of view, [excess cash] is wasteful.

Noone was saying that 12 months ago.

Re:Google In Discussions To Acquire Yelp For A Half Billion ... by willwagner on Friday December 18, 2009 @12:39AM (#1002603)
This seems like a good marriage to me (or is it an adoption?). More and more on google, I see adsense results that are local in nature, and with more focus on android, this is a perfect addition to get more ad real estate that is location based.

I use a lot of iphone apps, but more often than not, when I have my wallet out, I use the Yelp app to purchase food or drink. As a user, I'd be much more reluctant to utilize an admob ad on an unrelated iphone app or game as opposed to clicking on an ad when I'm trying to find a good thai restaurant somewhere in the midwest.

Re:Google In Discussions To Acquire Yelp For A Half Billion ... by jsm386 on Friday December 18, 2009 @01:56AM (#1002721)
This would actually perfectly compliment the new PlaceRank effort in which Google is sending out all of those QR stickers - Think foursquare for check in + Yelp userbase/content + locally targeted adwords, and throw in AdMob.

About the stickers: http://www.techcrunch.com/2009/12/16/check-in-google-foursqu...

Re:Google In Discussions To Acquire Yelp For A Half Billion ... by malbiniak on Thursday December 17, 2009 @10:39PM (#1002497)
you'll never, ever, ever hear me say this ever again: i thought scoble made some interesting points (when he talked about facebook acquiring yelp). http://scobleizer.com/2009/03/26/facebook-is-lucky-it-missed...

but what does google have to gain? extend google maps/local? aren't they already scraping reviews and ratings? screw the "don't be evil," what's in it for them...especially at $500M?

and as a random peanut gallery jab, it kills me how "past the term sheet stage" indicates an 80% probability. isn't anything past .01% "past the term sheet stage?"

Re:Google In Discussions To Acquire Yelp For A Half Billion ... by jgilliam on Friday December 18, 2009 @01:31AM (#1002679)
Yelp has a lot of relationships with local businesses, something they are trying to grow with AdWords.

They also want the dataset. The current reviews google is crawling are lousy compared to Yelp's.

Re:Google In Discussions To Acquire Yelp For A Half Billion ... by Raphael on Friday December 18, 2009 @04:37AM (#1002864)
The main purpose of the buyout is to kill competition, IMO.
Re:Google In Discussions To Acquire Yelp For A Half Billion ... by aresant on Friday December 18, 2009 @04:16AM (#1002836)
To max out profit Google may as well own the top 10 listings they display under major search terms (Knol) and long-tail local search (Yelp).

That should cover 50% of profitable searches yes?

Toddling monopoly?

Re:Google In Discussions To Acquire Yelp For A Half Billion ... by leej on Friday December 18, 2009 @12:08PM (#1003447)
i wonder if msft allows google to grab yelp too.