News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Surprising History of Copyright and the Promise of a ... by norea-armozel on Thursday August 06, 2015 @04:05PM (#10019043)
You own your labor. It's not unlike any other job where you have to put in time to get something out of it. As a programmer, I don't own any line of code or algorithm which I leverage. I am skilled labor, pure and simple. And you as an artist are also skilled labor.

The question should be how to monetize your labor? That answer isn't easily given but I can guess it would require a whole new method of payment. For example, a musician in the vast majority of cases lives from the money earned in performances as very few are writers of their own songs (that's where the current money is found in terms of the music industry). Thus, musicians would monetize as they always have, through payment for performances. It's when you get into writing lyrics or entire songs (sheet music plus lyrics) is where things may become complex. If the writer and musician are the same person then the person would have to default to performances to ensure some measure of payment. As for the song itself, that would be something left to the creator to figure out.

As for writing books, well that's even more complex at least in terms of reprints. But first runs would still go through publishers like Amazon which means there's some guarantee of revenue (just not to the projected sums you may assume). But today's small time writer isn't working the gravy train any more than the musician is. If anything, both musician and writer are just could/would be profiteers.

It's blind luck either profession finds success. Copyright doesn't offer much in the way of protection. What happens now is that human beings in general value your work. Thus pay you as we do now. Copyright is just the formality to prevent non-payment from other parties such as publishers. Copyright today isn't much of a benefit even there since many publishers write contracts to their advantage. What should happen is that copyright should largely (and in my opinion solely) apply to companies. And it should be by default that the majority of all proceeds be held in trust to the creator of the work even if the company in question offered the means to produce said proceeds. I think this approach would go further to ensure artists and content creators have a better chance at a livable wage. But it shouldn't include lifetime of the creator plus X years in any capacity. It should be up the creator of the work to register for the copyright as before the 1970s. And it should be easy as filling out a form on the web with a copy of the original work in question for verification with the US Copyright office or its analogs in other countries.

Re:The Surprising History of Copyright and the Promise of a ... by anigbrowl on Thursday August 06, 2015 @05:57PM (#10019739)
As a programmer, I don't own any line of code or algorithm which I leverage. I am skilled labor, pure and simple. And you as an artist are also skilled labor.

No, that's an economic decision you made to enter into a work-for-hire arrangement instead of selling your own product/service - whose assets you would own - and you are now trying to foist that economic arrangement on other people who don't want to enter into it.

But today's small time writer isn't working the gravy train any more than the musician is. If anything, both musician and writer are just could/would be profiteers.

Well, excuse me for wanting to create and sell my own literary product. WTF.

What should happen is that copyright should largely (and in my opinion solely) apply to companies. And it should be by default that the majority of all proceeds be held in trust to the creator of the work even if the company in question offered the means to produce said proceeds.

It seems as if you propose establishing a more equal playing field by abolishing the economic incentive for capital owners to invest money in the production of cultural goods.

It should be up the creator of the work to register for the copyright as before the 1970s. And it should be easy as filling out a form on the web with a copy of the original work in question for verification with the US Copyright office or its analogs in other countries.

Well, this is how it works now if you want to recover statutory damages. I create work, I pay $50 to register with the copyright office and supply a deposit copy, eventually I get a receipt and if someone infringes on the copyright I can recover punitive damages. Otherwise I'm limited to economic damages which are a lot trickier to recover, as many infringers can hide behind shell companies and just let them go bankrupt. In practice publication deals typically require that the copyright be registered in advance of the deal so as to avoid messy and expensive litigation at a later date over exactly when the work was created, likewise many publishers prefer to be approached by attorneys or literary agents rather than by authors, precisely because those professionals will have the legalities in order at the commencement of negotiations and publishers will know exactly what they're buying.

Re:The Surprising History of Copyright and the Promise of a ... by norea-armozel on Friday August 07, 2015 @10:05AM (#10022530)
No, that's an economic decision you made to enter into a work-for-hire arrangement instead of selling your own product/service - whose assets you would own - and you are now trying to foist that economic arrangement on other people who don't want to enter into it.

Nope, it's a reality. The majority of people who work are not business or capital owners. It's a fact of capitalism which is not immutable.

Well, excuse me for wanting to create and sell my own literary product. WTF.

Then deal with the hard reality that being a writer isn't always profitable just as being a programmer isn't always profitable. The market does not promise any ROI for any vocation or enterprise. You have to see it through like the rest of us.

It seems as if you propose establishing a more equal playing field by abolishing the economic incentive for capital owners to invest money in the production of cultural goods.

Capital owners are the problem with our economy, yes.

Otherwise I'm limited to economic damages which are a lot trickier to recover, as many infringers can hide behind shell companies and just let them go bankrupt.

And yet the primary target of copyright infringement these days are kids who torrent the latest Taylor Swift album. I'm sorry if I'm not sympathetic to your cause when the actual infringers have no money of their own or little of it to give to you.

In the end, you seem very much invested in keeping the status quo where it's impossible to achieve a practical method to recover losses. The current system is built with the assumption that one size fits all. The reality is that there is no one size fits all solution. If you want to recover losses from the teenager who torrented your work then figure out a monetization scheme. Don't go to a lawyer and bully a kid who probably doesn't even have a personal checking account. Figure out how to price it right for that kid. Otherwise, just get out of the market place because your reaction is like that of certain libertarians I've debated where they justify the killing of a kid who steals a stick of bubblegum from a news stand.

Re:The Surprising History of Copyright and the Promise of a ... by api on Thursday August 06, 2015 @05:20PM (#10019530)
If you only own your labor, you are a serf.
Re:The Surprising History of Copyright and the Promise of a ... by norea-armozel on Thursday August 06, 2015 @05:25PM (#10019561)
That's the only thing anyone can own in reality. The other concepts of property can only exist with the mechanisms of the State. Capitalism in this function is an organ of the State and can only operate within a State since without a monopoly on force (be it a tribal council, a brutal tyrant, a publicly traded company, or a democracy) there's no means to deprive others of their labor or the product of their labor. And that is exactly what copyright does as a side effect.

So, within a State we have to ask the question regarding how to best protect both labor and the products of someone's labor. It's not as easy as writing a computer program to be sure. I'm just pointing out that effectively all copyright doesn't effectively pay a proper wage as like all titled property it benefits those who can leverage the legal system to their favor. And historically speaking, copyright law has inevitably favored those who can pay the lawyers the most which is not the vast majority of creators (as labor).

Re:The Surprising History of Copyright and the Promise of a ... by williamcotton on Thursday August 06, 2015 @06:00PM (#10019759)
90% of copyright is handling registrations and settling transfers, updating the account books at various places... just a shit ton legal and accounting grunt work. We've got skyscrapers filled with said grunts all over the Western world.

Enforcement has always been separate, even before copyright and from the very beginnings of the Stationers monopoly.

Despite the existence of the High Commission, the reality of censorial control of the press at this time did not primarily lie with the stationers. Certainly, they had a role to play in the politics and practice of sixteenth century censorship,[24] but in fact it was not the stationers but rather "[t]wo long-standing institutions, parliament and the royal prerogative, [that] proved to be Elizabethan England's most useful means for effecting censorship" [Clegg, Press Censorship in Elizabethan England, 19]

http://www.copyrighthistory.org/cam/tools/request/showRecord...

It really could just be as easy as writing a computer program. Spotify is basically a voluntary collection agency that honors IP contracts.

If we can make it so the legal and accounting services are computerized, with software both writing and enforcing contracts, we could make copyright registration and transfer settlement incredibly cheap. That's the main reason why copyright law has favored those who can pay the lawyers and accountants the most, they have always been necessary in order to make the entire system function.

Re:The Surprising History of Copyright and the Promise of a ... by norea-armozel on Friday August 07, 2015 @09:58AM (#10022486)
Bingo. That's why I oppose copyright as it is both from a moral standpoint and the current legal reality of it. If real reforms could be passed that would focus on the creator of the original work and less on the owner of the copyright license then I could see this being as simple as paying a bar tab. It just seems people focus too much on the creators of content without realizing they're not the actual beneficiary of the current legal regime.
Re:The Surprising History of Copyright and the Promise of a ... by anigbrowl on Thursday August 06, 2015 @06:42PM (#10019897)
like all titled property it benefits those who can leverage the legal system to their favor

The potential inequity of litigation outcomes doesn't mean that I would be better off without this property right.

Re:The Surprising History of Copyright and the Promise of a ... by norea-armozel on Friday August 07, 2015 @09:55AM (#10022466)
And yet history has proven that property rights of this kind don't actually give more to the creator. When Eli Whitney patented the cotton gin he fought for years in court against the makers of copycat versions of the cotton gin. Oddly, when he went into rifling of gun barrels he chose not to patent a single part of the process. He used trade secrets and focused on improving his products.

It's not a 1-to-1 comparison to copyright of music and art but I think the principle still applies. Focus on making a product someone wants. If you can't price it property the first time then try another price or business model.