News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Surprising History of Copyright and the Promise of a ... by anigbrowl on Thursday August 06, 2015 @03:34PM (#10018827)
Artists who can't derive a living by these means should look into alternate means of making a living. Success as an artist is not an entitlement. Creative people who make creative works will succeed in proportion to their ability to be valued by society or a subset of it, not because society can correctly identify any objective or intrinsic value in any particular creative work.

In other words success is correlated with successful marketing rather than any intrinsic value of the work. So even if the work is great and popular, authors of said works hould not be allowed to have an economic interest in its distribution.

It's also not comparable to the "wealthy engineers" you malign. If engineers worked under the same terms as modern copyright never a road or bridge or factory would be built because the next hundred years of paying royalties to all the engineers on top of construction costs would make it impossible to build anything.

Utter, unmitigated bullshit. You're saying that there is really no such thing as original work, which is patently untrue.

Re:The Surprising History of Copyright and the Promise of a ... by norea-armozel on Friday August 07, 2015 @10:22AM (#10022622)
Utter, unmitigated bullshit. You're saying that there is really no such thing as original work, which is patently untrue.

Name one story in modern movies that doesn't follow at least part of commonly identified narratives. Name one painting that doesn't follow some common themes (Madonna and child comes to mind). Name one written work that doesn't have some intertextual references. Hell, name one superhero that isn't a knock off of another.

If you can't then will you admit that everyone borrows ideas from everyone else?