Re:‘Stay Far, Far Away’ and Other Things Gleaned from Yelp H...
by henrikschroder on Thursday August 06, 2015 @02:57PM
(#10018573)
There are studies that show that sticking needles into the skin have various positive effects, but the whole chi/meridians/acupuncture points is complete pseudoscience.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:‘Stay Far, Far Away’ and Other Things Gleaned from Yelp H...
by belenos46 on Thursday August 06, 2015 @03:36PM
(#10018842)
So sticking needles places --which is what acupuncture does-- works fine, but the names used to describe it --which is what that chi/meridians stuff is-- mean that it's bunk? Why --because you saw a bunch of films attributing magic powers to chi? How are those films significantly different than any science-based event in any Hollywood film ever?
Re:‘Stay Far, Far Away’ and Other Things Gleaned from Yelp H...
by pluma on Thursday August 06, 2015 @05:05PM
(#10019440)
The difference is that acupuncturists claim that it is far more nuanced than it has been scientifically proven to be and justify that claim with a lot of pseudo-scientific woo.
There is basis for the claim that sticking needles in people can help with some ailments. There is no basis for the claim that meridians are a thing and in any way relevant to those effects.