I'm sure being an ER physician can handle the stress, because they aren't interacting with the patients like the nurses and techs interact with the patients. Have they ever had someone hit them because they didn't get their turkey sandwich fast enough? Spit in their face because they were made NPO? Pee on them on purpose? I sincerely doubt it. The scope of practice is entirely different. I think the nurses and techs do an incredible job of keeping it together and maintaining a friendly demeanor towards patients when they have to put up with these things. It's easy for you to say 'If you can't handle the stress, get training or change departments'. That's exactly the response that causes nursing to have such a high turnover and burnout rate.
No one is advocating for staff to be rude, I'm advocating, however, for better ratios for the nursing staff and more patient education on the other side of healthcare. And frankly, I think that sometimes, it should be okay for healthcare workers to interact with a patient like they are an asshole because THEY ARE. You'll get the same standard of care, but I'll be damned if I'm going to go to another floor to search for some ice cream for you after you called me every name in the book and pulled out your IV for the third time in the past 4 hours because you didn't like that I still won't give you another dose of dilauded...and you're in the hospital because you're diabetic and morbidly obese.
And I'm on the practitioner's side here. And yes I can see that this influences ratings. My quick one liner about evaluation of facility vs. independent doctor may be confusing in that the rest was not addressing evaluation but rather treatment of patients.
"Have they ever had someone hit them because they didn't get their turkey sandwich fast enough? Spit in their face because they were made NPO? Pee on them on purpose? I sincerely doubt it."
Yes and worse. But given that, I can certainly see that this is the status quo for nurses/techs and not for doctors so I can certainly sympathize. I'm not defending these actions.
"'If you can't handle the stress, get training or change departments'. That's exactly the response that causes nursing to have such a high turnover and burnout rate."
Yes, it is easy for me to say, but my ease by no means releases someone from their responsibility to control their emotions under stress. And I'd like to hear more about that being the reason for high turnover.
"I'm advocating ... more patient education on the other side of healthcare."
Ha! In the U.S. this is a lost cause. I do agree with you completely, but the system is set up in such a way that medical knowledge is abstracted away from normal life/people to a ridiculous degree. And both parties, the lay and the physicians, seem to prefer this. Incredible!
"And frankly, I think that sometimes, it should be okay for healthcare workers to interact with a patient like they are an asshole because THEY ARE."
('you' used in the third person below)
If that means reacting in kind then I disagree. If you're rude to a rude person then you're a rude person. If you decide that somehow a rude person deserves a lesser degree of care then you should get reacquainted with medical ethics.
You did add "You'll get the same standard of care." So the above is a general comment and not 'aimed' at you personally.
Assault = police.
Irritability is a part of suffering.
I was not addressing this at all. Patient satisfaction scores are a lot more broad than "staff was friendly, check".
I even state the following "And I don't consider saying 'no' to a low priority case as negative treatment."
I have family and friends that are ER physicians (and have done it in multiple countries), and they can handle the stress of stressed patients without needing to resort to stress induced interaction themselves. This is all that I was referring to.
I do not tolerate rude medical staff, and no one should. Again, if you can't handle the stress, get training or change departments.