The things which actually matter like total cost and effectiveness of treatment, etc. Are hard for a single person to judge -teams would have to study and compare data, rather than feelings.
So what we can end up getting, if this how doctors get reviewed, is them acting more as feel good doctors, than actual physicians giving you hard advice.
I don't care how good a chef at a restaurant is, if it takes me 2 hours to order and wait for food, the silverware is dirty, and the surroundings are miserable, I'm never coming back.
Already in this story you see the effect of massage therapists being statistically advantaged over internal medicine doctors. That's obviously silly, but the same effect happens within the medical profession, between different doctors.
/endrant
But the next tier after that will be a raft of professionals who are not necessarily effective, but still apt at customer service. Elevating them is a loss for consumers.
The question you then want to ask is, is it harder to be good at customer service, or harder to be good at internal medicine? I think customer service is easier, and thus worry that the second tier will be the largest of the tiers.
An easy response to this is to say that doctors will learn to get better at customer service. Maybe. But the effect I'm talking about also happens if we stipulate that none of these professionals really change at all, and instead the market just changes the way we sort them. I think that is likelier than the scenario where doctors who are not simultaneously good at medicine and managing an office suddenly figure out customer service.
In conclusion, it is a nice idea to think of the doctors as "business people" but the reality is there are fewer and fewer who are. Most are now employees in a large corporate system.
(also +1 to the sibling comments)
* did I have a long wait time?
* was the office staff polite and helpful?
* was my physician/NP/PA polite and helpful?
* were there billing problems after the appointment?
These things do matter, but there are more important factors in play that patients are not in a position to judge:
* were standards of care followed by the provider?
* were unnecessary tests ordered or unnecessary drugs proscribed?
* were necessary tests skipped or necessary drugs not proscribed?
* if they had access to my medical history, did the provider bother to review it before seeing me
* etc, etc.
Quality of care can absolutely be evaluated, and that's happening more and more, it's just that patient satisfaction is only one small part of the whole picture.