News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why pre is better than post production code review by sytse on Wednesday August 05, 2015 @05:45PM (#10013099)
I agree sometimes you need to review a piece of functionality. But I think of this more of an escalation of a change set review. As in: 'this code stinks, why is that, lets look at the bigger picture, mmmm, lets schedule a review for this'. From the article: "It’s possible that a larger piece of code needs refactoring. If this is the case, do it within the merge request or schedule the refactoring as a separate issue.".
Re:Why pre is better than post production code review by sheepmullet on Wednesday August 05, 2015 @07:18PM (#10013553)
> I agree sometimes you need to review a piece of functionality. But I think of this more of an escalation of a change set review.

I find it's more like the difference between unit testing and integration testing. No matter how well you unit test it doesn't replace integration testing.

Most of the bugs I run into in prod are not the result of localised issues but are rather caused by the interplay of different modules/classes/subsystems.

Re:Why pre is better than post production code review by sytse on Wednesday August 05, 2015 @07:43PM (#10013675)
I agree there is scale in this. My point is that the smaller ones (here is a bug we need to fix/code with high churn) are the best way to find the larger ones (here is code we need to refactor.