Re:It Just Works
by danielweber on Wednesday August 05, 2015 @03:42PM
(#10012301)
I believe that Apple and Google got permission from the labels to do it.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Fair use shouldn't require permission.
Re:It Just Works
by danielweber on Wednesday August 05, 2015 @03:49PM
(#10012347)
Saying it was fair use is begging the question. It's not obvious that showing I own a CD at one point means I get online access to files ripped off an equivalent CD forever.
Not really. It required you to have the files to be allowed to stream them back to yourself, the most essential functionality was de-duplication + streaming of content that you already had while you were on the move.
And if you own a CD at some point nothing stops you from ripping it and selling the original (that's still illegal, but you could do it) so it's impossible to check.
I don't see why google should get a free pass on this, it seems to have to do with size rather than with the technology or the law.