Re:Insurgents Hack U.S. Drones
by motters on Thursday December 17, 2009 @10:17AM
(#1001147)
Having an unencrypted video broadcast on a military drone is just a dumb idea by whoever manufactured it. Encryption would seem to be the most minimal requirement for such an application.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I agree that the transmission should be encrypted, but I think the usefulness of the video feed to insurgents is overstated. You can hear and see the drones overhead, so it is pretty clear if your area is under surveillance.
Re:Insurgents Hack U.S. Drones
by LostInTheWoods on Friday December 18, 2009 @12:05AM
(#1002575)
You can not hear and see the drones. That is what makes them such an effective weapon.
I agree. My first thought when reading the article was "WTF? No encryption?". Would be interested in learning more about the company that makes these, and how something so obvious was not done.
If they were first deployed in the 1990's, the technology was developed in the 1980's. Easily deployable software to grab the signals out of the air was probably outside the realm of what seemed possible then.
Why it hasn't been fixed since is shocking!
Consumer satellite TV was around from the early 80's, and the struggle to scramble the signal in ways that people wouldn't get around to get free TV started promptly... They really had no excuse - while they might not expect some random guy with a little dish and a laptop, they should have been expecting hostile governments from easily having the capability.
Re:Insurgents Hack U.S. Drones
by stcredzero on Thursday December 17, 2009 @12:12PM
(#1001380)
Reminds me of Brian Singer's documentary "Spin," which is no longer available on YouTube. It was made of raw Satellite feed going down to local news stations.
some of it is here http://www.brasschecktv.com/page/43.html
I don't buy this.
Well, to be more accurate, I believe what you're saying, but I don't believe that it is a valid excuse.
Most of the functionality of these drones could be duplicated with nearly off-the-shelf hardware. (at least off-the-shelf for Boeing/Lockheed/General Dynamics/Raytheon/etc).
Easily deployable software to grab the signals out of the air was probably outside the realm of what seemed possible then
Not for the Russians it wasn't! Nor for the French, who will happily sell weapons to whoever wants them (as we Brits learnt in the Falklands War).