Depending on the duration of the key press, you can send the machine to sleep, get the traditional shut down window, or invoke the forced power-off incantation, according to this support article [1].
The short tap-for-sleep method doesn't seem to work on the machine I'm using, either.
Thanks. That's something that would have been really helpful to see a note on. It changed the behavior of a button that's been consistent for as long as I can remember.
Press and hold. It's this way to prevent accidental logouts which were frequent in my case when it was just a press.